Features

Send a link to a friend

Who invents better products -- individual inventors or corporations?

By Paul Niemann

[JAN. 6, 2005]  Before we move on to a brand-new year of invention news, I'd like to pause for one of the more important news items of 2004: the breakup of Barbie and Ken after a 43-year courtship.

Barbie and Ken who?

I'm referring to the Barbie doll and her commitment-phobic boyfriend, Ken, who called it quits in February. Their publicist said, "They'll always remain the best of friends." Yeah, I'm sure that's going to make die-hard fans of Barbie and Ken feel better.

How is this relevant to our story, or is your humble scribe just going off on a tangent again?

The dolls have something in common with many of the popular inventions that people use every day, because they were created by an individual inventor, Mattel co-founder Ruth Handler).

Where do inventions come from? Are the best products invented by individual inventors or by big companies?

For many brand-new products, the chances are good that they were created by individual inventors. But products that are either high-tech or are variations of existing products (think Diet Coke) were probably created in corporate labs.

Individual inventors often face nearly insurmountable odds in the invention process because they don't have existing brand names to capitalize on and they usually don't have retail stores set up to carry their new inventions. Oh, and there's that pesky little detail about paying for the cost of inventing and marketing.

From board games such as Monopoly and Trivial Pursuit, invented by two Canadians, to toys like Furby, invented by Richard Levy, and Rubik's Cube, invented by Erno Rubik of Hungary, it was the work of individual inventors that brought us these products. The same goes for appliances like the George Foreman Grill (sorry, but it was Michael Behm, not George Foreman) and anything that comes from Ron Popeil, of Ronco fame.

Individual inventors create new products in every imaginable industry, from hardware inventions like the Black & Decker Workmate to sporting goods inventions like the modern baseball glove, by Cardinals pitcher Bill Doak in 1920, and the snowboard, by Jake Burton. In the case of Black & Decker, it was Englishman Ron Hackman, an individual inventor, who invented the Workmate and licensed it to the company.

[to top of second column in this article]

Think that TV and radio were invented by RCA or Zenith? Think again, as it was 17-year-old Idaho farm boy Philo Farnsworth who invented TV and Croatian immigrant Nikola Tesla who invented radio.

The next time you drive somewhere in the rain, you can thank Alabama's Mary Anderson for inventing windshield wipers in 1903 or Robert Kearns for inventing intermittent windshield wipers in 1964. Both were individual inventors.

If you prefer flying, credit goes to Wilbur and Orville for getting you there. If your plane doesn't make it all the way to your destination, you'll be forever grateful to Capt. Tom Baldwin and his brother, inventors of the parachute.

And we haven't even mentioned some of the all-time great individual inventors, such as Leonardo da Vinci, Ben Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, George Washington Carver or Thomas Edison, who went on to create his own corporate lab.

Back to the original question of this story: Who invents better products -- individual inventors or corporations?

That would be impossible to answer in one column, as we would have to compare the results of thousands of individual inventors versus thousands of corporations. As Invention Mysteries begins its third year of syndication, we will continue to focus on the stories of the individual inventors.

[Paul Niemann]

Paul Niemann is the author of Invention Mysteries. He can be reached at niemann7@aol.com.

© Copyright Paul Niemann 2005


Previous columns

Back to top


 

News | Sports | Business | Rural Review | Teaching & Learning | Home and Family | Tourism | Obituaries

Community | Perspectives | Law & Courts | Leisure Time | Spiritual Life | Health & Fitness | Teen Scene
Calendar | Letters to the Editor