Erskine and Newcombe had plenty of company as pitchers for the Dodgers in their first four years in Los Angeles, having to ply their trade at a facility that was never meant for baseball.
Routine fly balls, popups actually, soared over a 42-foot high screen in left field, where the distance from home plate to the foul pole was a ridiculous 251 feet.
"I won't say it was a joy to pitch in the Coliseum," Newcombe said. "You felt like you were shaking hands with the left fielder."
Working in his second game at a stadium built for track and football, Erskine faced Chuck Tanner leading off the ninth with the Dodgers leading the Chicago Cubs by a run.
"I gave him a high fastball that hit him on the fists. He hit it on the handle straight down the left field line and out," the 81-year-old Erskine recalled. "As the umpire threw me a new ball while Tanner ran around the bases, I kept glaring at that left-field screen.
"What I wanted to do was throw that new ball over the screen to show how cheap that home run was, to show I could throw a ball that far."
Modern-day pitchers will get a taste of what it was like Saturday night when the World Series champion Boston Red Sox visit for an exhibition game at the Coliseum as part of the Dodgers' 50th anniversary celebration of their move from Brooklyn.
Actually, it will be even more challenging, because the distance from the plate to the foul pole will be only 201 feet, although batters will have to clear a 60-foot screen.
"It'll be interesting and definitely something that will be talked about for years," Boston's Kevin Youkilis said. "(Batting practice) could be interesting."
The Dodgers said Friday that the full allotment of 115,300 tickets - with all the proceeds going to ThinkCure, the Dodgers' official charity
- have been sold, including about 25,000 for standing-room only behind the lower fence in right and center fields. Two big-screen TVs will make it possible to watch the action.
Baseball's current world record is an estimated 114,000 for an exhibition game between the Australian national team and an American services team during the Olympic Games in Melbourne, Australia, in 1956.
"I just feel like this is a huge dividend for an old-timer," said Newcombe, the longtime director of community relations for the Dodgers.
Among other old-timers expected to attend are a pair of former left-handed hitters
- Wally Moon, a journeyman who earned lasting fame for his ability to slice the ball off or over the left field screen, known as Moonshots, and Duke Snider, a Hall of Famer driven to distraction because the outfield fence in the power alley in right field was 440 feet away.
Now 81, Snider remembers Willie Mays' reaction to the dimensions at the Coliseum.
"(Mays) said: `Duke, it kills you. Look at that right-field fence,'"
Snider remembered. "He started laughing. `They had to put some real estate
on the field. They put it all in right field.'
"It was not and never will be a baseball stadium even though baseball was played there."
Maybe not, but the Dodgers beat the Chicago White Sox in the 1959 World Series. They moved to Dodger Stadium in 1962.
The Dodgers acquired Moon for outfielder Gino Cimoli after the 1958 season, and he was an immediate success with an inside-out swing that sent the ball toward left on a regular basis.