Alex Rodriguez hit a colossal home run, Curtis Granderson also connected and New York got back on track with an 11-7 victory Friday night in a game that quickly grew testy.
"Sometimes it doesn't really matter if it's on purpose," Rodriguez said. "There's no question, it was very important for us to bounce back and play our type of baseball."
Girardi and Acta got into a heated argument when both benches and bullpens emptied after Teixeira was hit behind the shoulder by a second-inning pitch from struggling Cleveland starter Fausto Carmona.
No punches were thrown and there appeared to be little pushing and shoving
- if any. Plate umpire Dale Scott issued warnings to both teams, and there was no further trouble.
"I have respect for Manny. I actually had a nice exchange with Manny at 3 o'clock today. But that doesn't mean there's not some feistiness in me and when my guys are getting plunked, I'm going to protect them," said Girardi, who gestured angrily at Carmona on the field. "I told him I thought he did it on purpose and I didn't like it."
Ivan Nova (5-4) pitched seven sharp innings for New York, and Derek Jeter had one hit to move within nine of 3,000. Jorge Posada, breaking out of a season-long slump, added three hits and an RBI on a night when his figurine was handed out to fans.
One of them sat on a ledge near the Yankees dugout as he singled home a run to cap a three-run first. Posada has four straight multihit games, raising average from .169 to .215.
"Just waiting for the ball longer and hitting it to all fields," he said. "Really seeing it better."
Rebounding from a three-game sweep by the Red Sox, their second at Yankee Stadium in a month, New York sent a wild Carmona (3-8) to his fifth straight loss and finished with 15 hits. The Yankees had dropped 10 of 14 at home.
"Forget who we're playing, you can't have teams be so comfortable against us," Rodriguez said. "I thought tonight was a good way to answer back and answer the call because the last three games at home was very embarrassing for us and it's really not acceptable for us to play that type of baseball."
Robinson Cano had three hits and an RBI, and Teixeira stroked a three-run double that made it 10-2 in the seventh. Rodriguez followed with an RBI double.
In the fourth, the three-time MVP hit his 625th career homer into the second row of bleacher seats in left-center, where an excited fan caught it on the fly. The ball sailed some 450 feet, beyond a loading-bay ramp that sits between Monument Park and the visitors' bullpen.
Yankees staff members could not remember a home run ever reaching that area at the new stadium, which opened in 2009.
"Unfortunately, it only counts for one," Rodriguez said.
Carlos Santana homered for the Indians, barely clinging to first place in the AL Central. Coming off a 1-6 homestand, they have lost 12 of 16 overall.
The opener of a four-game series was the first meeting this season between the teams. It didn't take long for both sides to get heated.
One pitch after Granderson hit his team-high 19th homer into the second deck in right to give New York a 4-0 lead, Carmona threw a pitch that was headed straight for Teixeira's upper back.
Teixeira ducked down and was hit squarely behind the right shoulder as he crumbled to the dirt. The slugger slammed down his helmet, then yelled and gestured at Carmona as he got up.