New U.S. and EU sanctions packages, announced with fanfare, were
seen as so mild that Russian share prices rose in relief. A small
number of names were added to existing blacklists, while threats to
take more serious measures were put on hold.
Nevertheless, Russian President Vladimir Putin responded by
threatening to reconsider Western participation in energy deals in
Russia, the world's biggest oil producer, where most major U.S. and
European oil companies have extensive projects.
Demonstrators smashed their way into the provincial government
headquarters in Luhansk, Ukraine's easternmost province, which abuts
the Russian border, and raised separatist flags over the building,
while police did nothing to interfere.
As night fell, about 20 rebel gunmen opened fire with automatic
weapons and threw stun grenades at the headquarters of the region's
police, trying to force those inside to surrender their weapons, a
Reuters photographer at the scene said.
"The regional leadership does not control its police force," said
Stanislav Rechynsky, an aide to Interior Minister Arsen Avakov,
referring to events in Luhansk. "The local police did nothing."
The rebels also seized the prosecutor's office and the television
The separatist operation in Luhansk appears to give the pro-Moscow
rebels control of a second provincial capital. They already control
much of neighboring Donetsk province, where they have proclaimed an
independent "People's Republic of Donetsk" and declared a referendum
on secession for May 11.
The rebels include local youths armed with clubs and chains, as well
as "green men" — heavily armed masked men in military uniforms
Adding control of Luhansk would give them sway over the entire
Donbass coalfield — an unbroken swath of territory adjacent to
Russia — where giant steel smelters and heavy plants account for
around a third of Ukraine's industrial output.
It is the heart of a region that Putin described earlier this month
as "New Russia", reviving a term from when the tsars conquered it in
the 18th and 19th centuries. Most people who live in the area now
identify themselves as Ukrainians but speak Russian as their first
Ukraine, a country of 45 million people the size of France, has a
thousand-year history as a state but has spent much of the last few
centuries under the shadow of its larger neighbor. It emerged as a
modern independent nation after the Soviet Union broke up in 1991,
with borders drawn up by Bolshevik commissars from territory
previously ruled by Russia, Poland and Austria.
Its current crisis erupted after a pro-Russian president was toppled
in February in a popular uprising. Within days, Putin had declared
the right to use military force and dispatched his undercover troops
to seize Crimea.
The United States and European Union accuse Moscow of directing the
uprising with the intent of dismembering Ukraine.
"Today, Russia seeks to change the security landscape of eastern and
central Europe," U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said in a speech
on Tuesday. "Whatever path Russia chooses, the United States and our
allies will stand together in our defense of Ukraine."
Nevertheless, U.S. and European officials have repeatedly made clear
they will not consider military action.
The U.S. embassy in Kiev described the behavior of pro-Russian
activists — who also attacked a rally of Kiev supporters on Monday
with clubs and iron bars, and are holding dozens of hostages
including seven unarmed European military monitors — as "terrorism,
pure and simple".
U.S. President Barack Obama, announcing new sanctions on Monday,
said they were intended to change Putin's "calculus".
But so far they have shown no sign of restraining the Kremlin
leader, who overturned decades of post-Cold War diplomacy last month
to seize and annex Ukraine's Crimea Peninsula and has since massed
tens of thousands of troops on the frontier. Russia has openly
threatened to invade to protect Russian speakers, though it denies
that it plans to do so.
Putin threatened on Tuesday to review the role of Western firms in
Russian energy deals.
"We would very much wish not to resort to any measures in response.
I hope we won't get to that point," Putin told reporters after
meeting leaders of Belarus and Kazakhstan.
"But if something like that continues, we will of course have to
think about who is working in the key sectors of the Russian
economy, including the energy sector, and how."
Russia's RTS stock index rose 1.23 percent on Tuesday in relief that
the latest EU and U.S. sanctions were so modest.
[to top of second column]
After Russia took Crimea in March, Washington and Brussels each drew
up sanctions blacklists that ban travel by and freeze the assets of
individuals and firms deemed to have played a role in threatening
Ukraine. The EU added 15 Russians and pro-Russian Ukrainians to its
blacklist on Tuesday, a day after Washington added seven individuals
and 17 firms to its own list.
But neither list includes any of
Russia's major firms.
The latest U.S. list names Igor Sechin, a long-time Putin ally who
now heads Russia's biggest oil company, Rosneft. But the firm said
the blacklisting of its boss would not affect its operations,
including plans to buy the oil trading arm of Wall Street bank
Sechin's name was conspicuously left off the EU list. European
countries do more than 10 times as much trade with Russia as the
United States, buying a quarter of their natural gas from Moscow.
They have been slower than Washington to embrace sanctions that
might jeopardize trade.
Moscow has shrugged off the blacklists as pointless, though
Washington and Brussels say they have had an indirect economic
impact by scaring investors into withdrawing capital.
"You have to look over the period of time Russia went into Crimea;
since we've imposed sanctions, there has been a quite substantial
deterioration in Russia's already weak economy," U.S. Treasury
Secretary Jack Lew told congressional hearings.
"We see it in their stock exchange, we see it in their exchange
rate, we see it in a number of important economic indicators."
Lew said Washington could also impose wider sanctions on Russian
industry. Obama said on Monday Western countries were keeping that
option "in reserve" in case of further escalation.
A hostage drama has kept the issue on the boil in European capitals.
On Friday, rebels captured eight unarmed European military monitors.
A Swede was freed three days later, but four Germans, a Dane, a
Czech and a Pole are still held in Slaviansk, a town rebels have
turned into a heavily fortified redoubt.
The self-declared "people's mayor" of the town, Vyacheslav
Ponomaryov, said on Tuesday he would discuss their release only if
the EU dropped sanctions against rebel leaders.
"If they fail to remove the sanctions, then we will block access for
EU representatives, and they won't be able to get to us. I will
remind my guests from the OSCE about this," he said, referring to
the European hostages. Nevertheless, he later met OSCE
representatives and said they had made "good progress" in
discussions on the release of the captives.
Ukraine's authorities are struggling to find a way to evict the
separatists, who also took a small town hall in Pervomaisk in the
Luhansk region on Tuesday and a number of buildings in another city
on Monday. Kiev launched an "anti-terrorist" operation in early
April, but it has yielded little so far.
The Russian Foreign Ministry said the EU sanctions would not ease
tensions in Ukraine.
"Instead of forcing the Kiev clique to sit at the table with
southeastern Ukraine to negotiate the future structure of the
country, our partners are doing Washington's bidding with new
unfriendly gestures aimed at Russia," the ministry said.
Gennady Kernes, the mayor of eastern Ukraine's biggest city,
Kharkiv, was in a stable condition on Tuesday in a hospital in
Israel, where he was flown after an assassination attempt. Kernes
was shot in the back on Monday.
(Additional reporting by John O'Donnell in Brussels, Pavel Polityuk
and Matt Robinson in Kiev, Darya Korsunskaya in Minsk, Steve
Gutterman, Elizabeth Piper, Oksana Kobzeva, Megan Davies, Olesya
Astakhova and Vladimir Soldatkin in Moscow; writing by Peter Graff;
editing by Will Waterman/Mark Heinrich)
[© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2014 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.