Lawyers started filing suits last Friday in West Virginia's
Kanawha County court, less than 24 hours after the first alarms were
sounded about the release of an industrial chemical into the Elk
None of the 18 cases filed against Freedom Industries, which owned
the leaky chemical storage tanks, and a water processing plant
upstream, have been certified yet as class actions, according to a
Several law firms are soliciting clients affected by the spill,
posting hotline numbers on their websites for legal advice.
"We're receiving calls by the minute regarding the situation that's
occurred following the spill," said Bernard Layne, a personal injury
attorney in the state capital Charleston who filed the first claim
when the court opened on Friday morning.
Restaurants and other businesses are suing to recover lost income
after the discharge of some 7,500 gallons (28,000 liters) of the
chemical 4-methylcyclohexane methanol, or Crude MCHM, from the
"For the restaurant owners, we have an economist that's looking at
their average income loss to make sure that we quantify that," said
Roger Decanio, another Charleston-based attorney.
"Many of these people live paycheck to paycheck, and now they have
to buy water and they are not working. The economic impacts are
huge. What the damages would be to repair that, I can't even begin
to fathom," Decanio added.
One suit in which Decanio's firm is involved was brought by a
dialysis patient whose kidney transplant was delayed because of a
lack of clean water. Another was filed by the owner of a local
Mexican cafe who told employees to stay home from work.
Decanio said he has not yet calculated how much money his clients
will be seeking, but said many lawyers were scrambling to file
claims quickly in case Freedom Industries declares bankruptcy,
anticipating heavy liabilities from the spill.
Freedom Industries, a Charleston company that produces specialty
chemicals for the mining, steel and cement industries, is the main
defendant in most of the cases.
West Virginia American Water Co, which runs the biggest water
processing plant in the state near the chemical storage facility,
was also named in some claims.
The county court's office could not confirm if the companies had
filed court papers related to the cases and neither company
responded to requests for comment.
[to top of second column]
So far, none of the lawsuits name state or local officials as
defendants, but plaintiffs lawyers say the West Virginia Department
of Environmental Protection or other agencies may become targets if
evidence is found of lax oversight.
The U.S. Chemical Safety Board said on Friday that federal
investigators were being deployed to the scene.
"When we are talking about a facility that is sitting right on our
fresh water supply and there is no one that is watching these tanks,
to me that's mind-boggling," Layne said. "Could one of the
regulatory agencies be involved eventually? I would rule nothing out
at this point."
It will be up to the assigned circuit court judges to decide whether
or not the claims meet the necessary criteria to be considered as
class-action suits, said Kanawha County court clerk Cathy Gatson.
"I wouldn't be surprised if (a class action) is certified," said
Edward Sherman, an expert on complex litigation at Tulane University
Law School in New Orleans. "They are all claiming they were injured
by an identical action by the defendant."
Attorney Anthony Majestro filed a motion over the weekend to group
the cases together for referral to the state's mass litigation
Water carrying the chemical MCHM has an odor like licorice or anise.
While not highly lethal, it can cause symptoms including nausea,
vomiting, dizziness, diarrhea, rashes and reddened skin.
The spill prevented residents from bathing or drinking tap water for
days and hundreds of people called the state poison center to report
health concerns, with a handful hospitalized.
On Monday, West Virginia officials lifted the tap water ban in some
areas of the state.
(Editing by Will Dunham and David Gregorio)
[© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2014 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.