After a well-received round in the United States in 2011,
American Pulitzer Prize finalist Gionfriddo's play opened at the
Hampstead Theatre in London last week, directed by Peter DuBois.
Critical reaction was mixed. The Guardian pointed out that
"while the play asks pertinent questions about the dilemmas
confronting women... it seems dismally reactionary in its
conclusion that public fulfillment and private happiness are
The Telegraph, on the other hand, called it a "highly
intelligent play" with "winning humor and palpable humanity".
The plot revolves around three former grad-school friends in
their 40s who reunite when Catherine, a glamorous, high-profile
academic and author, leaves her high-flying New York lifestyle
to return to her small hometown and care for her mother Alice,
who has just suffered a heart attack.
Living next door are her ex-boyfriend Don (Adam James) and his
wife, the controlling stay-at-home mother Gwen (Emma Fielding).
To keep herself busy Catherine, played by Emilia Fox, holds
summer classes in which she lectures on feminism, pornography
and horror films to her only students, Gwen and her former
babysitter, the irreverent 21-year old Avery (Shannon Tarbet).
In a series of scenes combining feminist theory and dry wit, the three women clash and end up exploring their own conceptions
of women's relations with men.
LONELY AND SAD?
Gionfriddo gives her characters plenty of time to discuss the
ideas of conservative Phyllis Schlafly, famous for her
opposition to the Equal Rights Amendment in the United States,
and those of Betty Friedan, whose work in the 1960s questioned
women's traditional role as domestic mothers.
[to top of second column]
"You either have a career and wind up lonely and
sad, or you have a family and wind up lonely and sad?", asks Avery,
as the two older women share their regret over the choices that led
to their polar opposite lives.
The discussions are peppered with a series of
bitingly funny jokes on sex, relationships and, believe it or not,
Google maps and pornography.
"No one buys the cow when you can get the milk for free," says
Alice, while sipping on one of her many martinis, in reference to
Avery's current relationship status as "hooking up exclusively" (and
strictly not the other way round).
During the course of the debates, both Catherine and Gwen end up
revealing their dissatisfaction with their lives and secret longing
for what they gave up — be it career or family.
"Being alone wasn't a problem until I faced losing my mother,"
Catherine remarks remorsefully.
Gwen's frustration at having given up college is
compounded by Don's utter lack of ambition in his job as a local
college dean. But the real problem is another one. He is addicted to
pot and pornography. The "tame" sort, he hastens to add in a later
Avery, meanwhile, is firmly pragmatic, refusing to see having a
career and a family as a zero-sum game.
Gionfriddo offers no panacea to the issue of navigating a career and
a family. The characters all have a stab at compensating for their
past decisions but wind up settling for their former, moderately
The question at the heart of the play, it seems, is left unresolved.
(Reporting by Julia Fioretti; editing by
Michael Roddy and Tom Heneghan)
[© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2014 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.