When the clamp failed, acrobats suspended by their hair plunged to
the ground in front of an audience of about 3,900. Eight performers
remained hospitalized, two in critical condition, on Monday
following the Sunday collapse during a Ringling Bros and Barnum &
Bailey Circus performance.
The steel carabiner clamp was the sole support of the welded steel
rigging developed by husband-and-wife team Andre and Viktoria
Medeiros, the latter of whom was among the eight people to fall.
Paul Doughty, investigator for the Providence Fire Department, said
it was not immediately clear why the carabiner, which was found
broken into three pieces, failed.
"In terms of the weight carrying capacity of the performance, it was
within its criteria," Doughty said. "There are dynamic forces that
The five-inch long carabiner was designed to hold up to 10,000
pounds (4,535 kg), far more weight than the 1,500 pounds (680 kg)
suspended at the time of Sunday's collapse, Doughty told reporters.
Movement of the rig, or of the performers, could have increased the
force on the carabiner.
Feld Entertainment, which owns the Ringling Bros circus, said it was
still studying the cause of the collapse.
"We will continue to inspect all of our equipment on our touring
shows, and we are replacing every carabiner on this unit before the
next performance," it said in a statement.
In addition to the two performers in critical condition, two were in
serious condition and four in good condition, according to a
spokeswoman for Rhode Island Hospital, where the acrobats were
brought after the collapse. Another performer was treated and
released on Sunday.
The eight hospitalized performers are Viktoria Medeiros, Widny
Neves, Samantha Pitard, Viktorila Liakhova, Dayana Costa, Julissa
Segrera, Stefany Neves and Svitlana Balanicheva, hospital officials
"The injuries were severe on some of the performers, but none appear
to be life threatening at this time," Feld spokesman Stephen Payne
said in an email.
The acrobats fell about 40 feet to the floor, hurting one performer
on the ground and stunning the audience, some of whom were initially
unsure if the drop was part of the act.
Video of the act showed the women falling quietly. The lights were
dimmed right after the drop.
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration is investigating
the cause of the collapse, a spokesman said.
"As with any OSHA inspection, its purpose will be to determine
whether or not there were any violations of workplace safety
standards in connection with this incident," said the spokesman,
Andre Bowser, adding that the agency could not estimate how long its
investigation would take.
[to top of second column]
'HIGH BURDEN OF PROOF'
OSHA has six months to investigate the accident and could then issue
citations to the company if it finds any legal violations. The
agency has a high bar to prove that the circus company violated
workplace safety standards, employment law experts said.
"That's a high burden of proof," said Edwin Foulke, a former OSHA
official who now serves as an attorney at law firm Fisher &
It would have to show the company knew the equipment that held the
performers was faulty, that it failed to perform proper inspections,
or that the company violated safety standards accepted throughout
the industry, he said.
Circuses have been cited for very few OSHA violations over the past
several years, he said.
"They recognize what they do is dangerous," Foulke said. "It's been
my experience that they are very, very safe."
OSHA can fine the company up to $70,000 for each "willful"
violation. It can also ask a company to abate any safety violations
it sees, which can affect the structure of a performance.
In 2010, for example, after a killer whale trainer at a SeaWorld
park was drowned after being pulled into a pool by an orca, OSHA
ordered SeaWorld to physically separate the trainers from the orcas
during performances, drastically altering the set-up of a marquee
event at the wildlife park.
Outside the arena where the circus incident occurred, people who had
held tickets for the canceled performances trickled in to collect
Anthony Fagundes, a funeral director from Cranston, Rhode Island,
said he had been watching the show with his wife and grandsons, ages
2 and 3, when the women fell.
"It was like a jinx ... We were all kind of stunned," Fagundes said,
adding that he had struggled to answer his older grandson's
questions about why the show had been suspended.
Feld said on Monday that the show would travel on to Hartford,
Connecticut, on Tuesday for performances scheduled for later this
(Additional reporting by Curtis Skinner and Carlyn Kolker in New
York; Writing by Scott Malone; editing by Andrew Hay and Peter
[© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2014 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.