The brunt of Tuesday's anti-China violence appears to have been
borne by Taiwanese companies in the zones in Binh Duong and Dong Nai
provinces, as rioters mistook the firms to be Chinese-owned. There
were no reports of casualties and the rioting appeared to have
subsided by Wednesday.
The row over the South China Sea and anti-China violence in
tightly-controlled Vietnam have brought relations between Hanoi and
Beijing to one of their lowest points since the Communist neighbors
fought a brief border war in 1979.
"I fear a dark chapter in Sino-Vietnamese relations is now being
written," said Ian Storey, a South China Sea expert at Singapore's
Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
"And because China wants to keep that oil rig in place into August,
these protests could just be the first pages."
Tran Van Nam, vice chairman of the Binh Duong People's Committee,
said workers initially held peaceful protests on Tuesday. But
disorder broke out when the numbers swelled to about 20,000.
Gates were smashed and rioters set 15 factories on fire, he said.
"This caused billions of dong (hundreds of thousands of dollars) in
damages and thousands of workers will have lost their jobs," Nam
said by telephone.
"We urge everyone to stay calm, exercise restraint and have faith in
the leadership of the Party and State."
F.Y. Hong, president of Taiwan's Formosa Industries Corp, one of the
companies that was attacked, said about 300 rioters looted
televisions, computers and personal belongings of workers.
"Due to the limited number of police, they couldn't stop the
looters. The situation was like in a country where there were no
authorities to protect its people," Hong said.
A police official in Binh Duong province, speaking by telephone,
said about 200 people had been arrested.
"We are working on other areas in the province ... We haven't seen
A Singapore foreign ministry spokesman said the premises of a number
of foreign companies were broken into and set on fire in two
Vietnam-Singapore joint venture industrial parks in Binh Duong. He
said the Singapore government had asked Vietnam to restore law and
order immediately, but gave no other details.
"Everyone is terrified," said Serena Liu, chairwoman of the Taiwan
Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam. "Some people tried to drive out of
Binh Duong, but looters had put up road blocks."
RISK OF MILITARY CLASH
Storey said the Vietnamese government would now be under increasing
pressure to respond, which could risk a military clash at sea with
China that Vietnam could not win.
Dozens of ships from both countries are around the oil rig, and the
two sides have accused each other of intentional collisions,
increasing the risk of open confrontation.
In Beijing, Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying told reporters
that China was seriously concerned about the violence and had
summoned Vietnam's ambassador to protest.
China has "demanded the Vietnamese side make efforts to adopt
effective measures to resolutely support eliminating illegal
criminal acts and protect the safety of Chinese citizens and
institutions", Hua told reporters.
Hong Kong-listed sports shoe maker Yue Yuen, which supplies footwear
to Adidas, Nike and other international brands, said it had
suspended production in Vietnam because of the protests, but there
was no damage to its facilities and its workers were safe.
[to top of second column]
A spokesman for global exporter Li & Fung, which supplies retailers
like Kohl's Corp and Wal-Mart Stores Inc with clothing, toys and
other products, said some of its suppliers in Vietnam had halted
production on Wednesday as a precautionary measure. He gave no
Anti-China sentiment was also evident in Manila,
as the Philippine government accused Beijing of reclaiming land on a
reef in disputed islands in another part of sea, apparently to build
"If these reports are true, this would represent a significant step
by the Chinese, potentially allowing them to extend their airborne
reach," said Storey, the analyst.
The spike in tensions over the oil- and gas-rich South China Sea
comes two weeks after U.S. President Barack Obama visited the region
and expressed support for long-time allies Japan and the
Philippines, both of which are locked in territorial disputes with
China. Vietnam is also stepping up ties with the United States.
CLAIMS AND COUNTER-CLAIMS
China claims almost the entire South China Sea, an area rich in
energy deposits and an important passageway traversed each year by
$5 trillion worth of ship-borne goods.
Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam also have
claims on the area.
Philippine foreign affairs department spokesman Charles Jose said
China had been moving earth and materials to Johnson South Reef,
known by the Chinese as Chigua and which the Philippines calls
Mabini Reef, in recent weeks.
He said China was reclaiming land in violation of the Declaration on
the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea, an informal code of
conduct for the region.
"I think they're to construct an airstrip there," Jose said.
However, Richard Bitzinger, a military analyst at the S. Rajaratnam
School of International Studies in Singapore, said the airstrip was
unlikely to be a strategic game-changer in the South China Sea
because of the difficulty in building a workable runway on the
"It would be a nice tool to have in the box of options to project
power, but it is probably going to be far too small to have a huge
impact," Bitzinger said.
"At this point I would be very surprised to see this develop into
any airbase of any significant size ... China's holdings in the
Spratlys are just too small.
"It is probably as much a political move as anything else, the
laying down of one more marker to solidify their position and
continue their campaign of creeping assertiveness."
(Additional reporting by Donny Kwok and Greg Torode in Hong Kong,
Faith Hung in Taipei, Nguyen Phuong Linh and Rachel Armstrong in
Singapore and Megha Rajagopalan and Michael Martina in Beijing;
Writing by Raju Gopalakrishnan; Editing by Mike Collett-White)
[© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2014 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.