Rubio, a likely 2016 presidential candidate, began a speech on
retirement policy by recalling the importance of Social Security and
Medicare to his immigrant parents. "They never earned enough to have
significant savings or a pension," he said. "It was Social Security
and Medicare that allowed them to retire with comfort and security."
Rubio then called for cutting Social Security benefits via a higher
retirement age, and shifting healthcare cost risk to seniors by "voucherizing"
Medicare. Both are standard-issue ideas for any Republican who wants
to be taken seriously by the party these days. And both would spell
disaster for an aging America already facing a huge shortfall in
But then Rubio did something bipartisan: He called for a
government-sponsored 401(k)-style retirement savings option for
working Americans who don't have such a plan. That sounds a lot like
a government solution to one of our most pressing retirement
security problems: the relatively low - and declining - level of
access to 401(k) plans. Just 52 percent of U.S. private-sector
workers had an employer-sponsored retirement plan of any kind in
2011, down from 62 percent in 2001, according to a National
Institute on Retirement Security analysis of Census Bureau data.
Rubio called for opening up the federal Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) to
private-sector workers. That's an idea Democrats and progressive
think tanks have proposed, since the TSP might just be the country's
best-run defined contribution plan. The TSP boasts very low costs, a
short and easy-to-understand set of investment choices and options
to convert savings into an annuity stream at retirement via a
third-party insurance company.
Rubio made the case this way: "The twisted irony is that members of
Congress - who are employees of the citizens of the United States -
have access to a superior savings plan, while many of their
employers - the American people - are often left with access to no
plan at all."
Well said. And the TSP isn't the only government-sponsored
retirement solution that has been proposed. The Obama Administration
is rolling out MyRa, a starter retirement account that would allow
participating employers to funnel worker contributions into low-risk
investments in an account held at the U.S. Treasury Department.
And the National Conference on Public Employee Retirement Systems, a
trade association for public-sector pension funds, has been pushing
a concept called Secure Choice Pension, which would be a low-cost
government-sponsored retirement savings vehicle that states could
offer to private-sector workers who don't have workplace plans.
California, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Illinois, Oregon and
Colorado are considering it, and Maryland created a task force this
week to study the issue.
[to top of second column]
The TSP is appealing because of its ultra-low fee structure. Its
average net expense ratio last year was just under three basis
points (a basis point is 1/100th of 1 percent). Private sector
401(k) plan costs don't come close to that: The average expense
ratio on mutual funds in those plans was 63 basis points in 2012,
according to the Investment Company Institute.
Fees are a critical factor in retirement saving. An analysis by the
Securities and Exchange Commission found that every 50 basis points
charged to a mutual fund reduces a $100,000 portfolio's value by
$10,000 over a 20-year period.
Rubio's arguments for whacking social insurance programs deserve to
go nowhere. But his pitch to open up the TSP should appeal to
progressives interested in cutting the cost of retirement saving,
and to conservatives who want to stress the importance of individual
"It's a great step and shows there really is potential for
bipartisan solutions to fix the private sector retirement system,"
says David Madland, managing director for economic policy at the
Center for American Progress. "Many people acknowledge that the
private system is broken and that we can do a lot to improve it."
For more from Mark Miller, see http://link.reuters.com/qyk97s
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist
(Follow us @ReutersMoney or at http://www.reuters.com/finance/personal-finance.
Editing by Douglas Royalty)
[© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2014 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.