In closing arguments, attorneys for the city and others worked to
convince U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Steven Rhodes that he should permit
Detroit to emerge from bankruptcy before Thanksgiving.
They largely presented a view of harmony, emphasizing the plan's
string of bilateral settlements had brought the biggest-ever
municipal bankruptcy to conclusion at record speed, mostly through
the groundbreaking "Grand Bargain." Under the deal, foundations, the
state and the Detroit Institute of Arts will pitch in funds to ease
pension cuts and avoid selling the city's art collection.
They also said Detroit's abundance of abandoned property provided
the broke city with a unique way to compensate creditors.
The judge, who began the confirmation hearing on Sept. 2, said he
will rule Nov. 7 on whether the 1,165-page plan is fair to creditors
and feasible for the city to implement.
The July 2013 bankruptcy filing was the city's only avenue for
addressing its fiscal woes, which included a big public pension
burden, said Bruce Bennett, an attorney at law firm Jones Day who
presented Detroit's closing arguments. About 150 court-ordered
mediation sessions helped bridge differences with creditors, he
"This plan is very broadly consensual at this point and the city has
settled with all the objectors and all the major economic players in
the city of Detroit," Bennett said.
The city's biggest financial risks would be to misspend $1.7 billion
targeted for restructuring and reinvestment initiatives, ignore
investments in capital projects and information technology, and
allow public pension funding to slide once again, Bennett said,
answering questions from Rhodes.
"The labor organizations have to put pension funding high on their
bargaining list," Bennett said.
Underfunding of the city's two retirement systems led Detroit to
issue more than $1.4 billion of pension debt in 2005 and 2006 that
became a lightning rod for contention in the bankruptcy case.
When the hearing ended, Kevyn Orr, Detroit's state-appointed
emergency manager, praised the plan for its "broad-brush consensus,"
noting he feared the case "would be volatile until the end."
[to top of second column]
The case started off contentiously but wrapped up with the two
largest holdout creditors, bond insurers Syncora Guarantee Inc and
Financial Guaranty Insurance Co, settling in recent weeks. Earlier
on Monday, an attorney for holders of much of the pension debt
announced they signed off on a deal.
Bennett defended bankruptcy fees to the judge, who suggested Detroit
turn to mediation or even litigation to ensure the costs are
"Are the city’s professional fees going to be high in a case like
this? Of course they are. Because they are high does that mean they
are unreasonable? Of course they are not," Bennett said.
As of Oct. 3, consultants had billed Detroit almost $137.2 million,
with the largest tab from Bennett's firm, Jones Day, for $52.3
million, according to data from Orr's office.
The bond insurers' settlements included options on city property,
which Bennett said allows creditors to invest in urban renewal while
saving Detroit money.
The "Grand Bargain" was instrumental in winning support from the
city's retirees. In his closing statement, Bennett said the city
could not be forced to sell assets like art to enhance creditor
recoveries - a point disputed by Syncora and FGIC before they
settled. He also said Detroit was literally taxed out.
"Detroit's taxes are higher than many cities in the state of the
Michigan and our services are not anywhere close to the best in
Michigan," he said.
(Reporting by Lisa Lambert; Additional reporting by Karen Pierog in
Chicago; Editing by Bernadette Baum, Andrew Hay and Richard Chang)
[© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2014 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.