Commentaries posted do not necessarily represent the opinion of LDN.
 Any opinions expressed are those of the writers.


Congressman Foster: Illinois is getting “rooked” on share of federal dollars; and more

Written By: Greg Bishop, INN News Reporter
 
 CONGRESSMAN FOSTER: ILLINOIS IS GETTING “ROOKED” ON SHARE OF FEDERAL DOLLARS
 A consumer research group says Illinois is less reliant on federal tax dollars than most other states, and an Illinois congressman says Illinois taxpayers are getting cheated.

Consumer research group WalletHub says Illinois ranks 45th among all the states when it comes to federal funds going back to states, something spokeswoman Jill Gonzales says means the Land of Lincoln is less reliant on federal dollars.

“One would be the most dependent, 50th the least dependent, so Illinois is pretty independent on it’s own,” Gonzales said.

However, Bill Foster, Democratic U.S. representative for the 11th District, said Illinois taxpayers aren’t getting their money’s worth when it comes to federal funding for things like education, infrastructure and social services.

“This forces us to eventually increase state taxes, which causes industrial flight,” Foster said.

Gonzales said the amount of a state’s gross domestic product plays a role.

“A low dependency on the federal government usually means a high GDP, and Illinois is definitely up there,” Gonzales said.

However, Foster said the reason Illinois gets fewer tax dollars from the federal government is because it’s among the larger states, which typically get less.

“The federal government should not be in the business of massive redistribution of wealth between the states,” Foster said.

Foster said one major problem is the lack of federal reimbursement for natural disasters to a state like Illinois, which saw flooding in the southern part of the state at the end of last year but no federal funds were awarded for cleanup efforts.

The WalletHub study can be found at this link: https://wallethub.com/edu/states-most-least-dependent-on-the-federal-government/2700/

CHARTER SCHOOL NETWORK HAS CONCERNS ABOUT CHARTER UNIONIZATION
While a charter school in Chicago is forming a union, the Illinois Network of Charter Schools wants to ensure other unions don’t impose.

Illinois law does not force a charter school to create a union, but does allow for the option among members.

The Illinois Federation of Teachers touts the recent vote approving a union for the Passages Charter School in the city’s West Edgewater neighborhood. Workers voted to join the Alliance of Charter Teachers and Staff Local 4343. However, Andrew Broy, president of the Illinois Network of Charter Schools, has some concerns.

Broy said there could be problems if the Chicago Teachers Union takes an interest in bargaining on behalf of charter school unions, noting, “I think they will likely make it more of a political statement than it will be a collaboration between teachers and management, and that does worry us long term.”

Broy said unions representing teachers at charter schools should work to retain flexibility to be innovative and to think about different staffing structures. Broy added, “To the extent that a union contract will prioritize a one-size-fits-all approach, that is counter to the charter model.”

Broy also said charter schools should not work against their best interests if a union is formed at a charter school.

[to top of second column]

“Provided that there’s an agreement to do it and the management and labor can work together to maintain charter autonomy, then it can work quite well,” Broy said.

Of the charters in Chicago, Broy said the majority have chosen to remain independent of unions and only two of the 15 charters outside of Chicago have a union.

Meanwhile Broy says 700 parents from across the state will be in Springfield Wednesday to lobby lawmakers in support of more charter school options.

THIRD PARTIES IN UPHILL BALLOT ACCESS BATTLE; MISS OUT ON MEDIA COVERAGE DURING PRIMARY
Last week was the first week that political parties other than Republicans and Democrats were able to circulate petitions to get on the November ballot in Illinois, and candidates are pointing out the large disparities in the process.

Libertarian candidate for state comptroller Claire Ball told WMAY Springfield she has to get at least five times more signatures than her Republican and Democrat opponents, which is 25,000 signatures — a big undertaking.

“We’re going to be out there every single day hitting up every train station, every event, every festival, just gathering signatures,” Ball said.

Meanwhile Rich Whitney, who ran as the Green Party candidate for governor in 2006 and 2010, said the process for new parties is like the Greek myth of Sisyphus.

“It’s like rolling that boulder up the hill and then it rolls back down over you and you have to start over again,” Whitney said.

As the Green Party candidate for governor Whitney, was able to get more than 10 percent of the vote in 2006, securing the Green Party as an established party. But in 2010 the party got below the threshold, which removed the party’s established classification.

Meanwhile new-party candidates say the problem isn’t just the disproportionate number of signatures they have to collect to get on the ballot, it’s also the months of missed political media coverage.


Per Illinois election law, new party candidates were allowed to circulate petitions beginning March 29. That’s two weeks after the March primary and nearly four months after Republicans and Democrats could begin collecting signatures and generating media coverage.

Libertarian candidate for U.S. Senate Kent McMillen said that missed media time is detrimental to fully informing voters. “They only focus on who is the most well-known or who makes the most outrageous statements,” McMillen said. “I believe that’s a disservice to the voters.”

Meanwhile Whitney said Illinois’ system is extremely unfair for parties other than Democrats and the GOP.

“It’s a tilted playing field,” Whitney said. “That’s what we have in the American political system today and nowhere is it more tilted than in Illinois.”

Click here to respond to the editor about this article

< Recent commentaries

Back to top