The panel reached its decision after the start of a probable cause
hearing in the case against Cardell Hayes, 28, prosecutors said.
Smith, one of the NFL’s top defensive ends before his 2014
retirement, was returning from a dinner with his wife on April 9
when police say a Hummer driven by Hayes struck the rear of Smith’s
Mercedes SUV and caused it to crash into another vehicle. The two
men exited their cars and exchanged words before Hayes drew a weapon
and fired multiple shots, police said.
Smith, 34, was hit by gunfire eight times and pronounced dead on the
scene. Smith’s wife, Racquel, was shot twice in the leg and
The grand jury also indicted Hayes on charges of aggravated assault
with a firearm and aggravated criminal damage to a vehicle.
Hayes faces a mandatory life sentence if convicted of second-degree
Hayes, who sat through the hearing in court shackles and wearing an
orange jumpsuit, did not speak. Through his lawyers, he pleaded not
guilty to all of the charges, and his bond was set at $1.75 million.
His lawyers said Hayes was not the aggressor but rather a victim of
a hit-and-run earlier in the evening.
Police have not verified that account, and have not confirmed that
the shooting was the result of road rage or offered any another
Thursday's session included a tense courtroom exchange in which
Hayes’ attorneys sparred with prosecutors, accusing them of rushing
the indictment to cut short the preliminary hearing.
[to top of second column]
John Fuller, an attorney for Hayes, was in the middle of questioning
a private investigator when the indictment was announced.
The investigator, David Olasky, testified that a witness told him
she had seen a man remove a gun from Smith’s SUV after the shooting.
Investigators have said they found a fully loaded 9mm handgun in
Smith’s car but that there was no indication that the weapon had
Will Smith played for the New Orleans Saints for a decade and was a
prominent member of the team during their Super Bowl victory in
2010. Following an injury in 2013, his contract was terminated and
he retired in 2014.
(Editing by Colleen Jenkins, Tom Brown and Bernard Orr)
[© 2016 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2016 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.