Edwards stumbles in bump and run on Harvick

Send a link to a friend  Share

[March 15, 2016]  By Jonathan Ingram, The Sports Xchange
 
 In golf parlance, Carl Edwards left the winning putt short. If it were football, he under threw an open receiver in the end zone as time expired. In basketball terms, he missed a game-winning layup

Or did he?

This is racing, where sometimes the rules are a little different. Did Edwards goof by letting the slower car and driver Kevin Harvick win the Sprint Cup race at Phoenix International Raceway on Sunday?

In the closest race at the Phoenix track since the Sprint Cup started racing there in 1988, Edwards came up 0.010 seconds short. On the last lap and in the final turns Edwards nudged Harvick, who banged doors with him once the Toyota driver was alongside and barely beat him to the finish stripe despite another bit of fender banging by Edwards.

Maybe Sprint Cup drivers have become too chummy and respectful to manhandle one another with the checkers in sight.

Edwards said he hit Harvick as hard as possible without wrecking him. The teams all work too hard, he said, to take away a victory by heavy contact even if his car was faster. "Those guys, everybody works hard here and if we would've had one more lap, I could have passed him clean," said Edwards. "But it just wasn't going to work without bumping him. So I decided to hit him as hard as I did. I really didn't want to wreck him, but I thought I moved him enough to get by, but that's just racing."

In a sport where the rules are often decided by the participants themselves, Edwards came down on the side of not taking a victory from the team that had been faster for the entire second half of the 500-kilometer event. But after a late caution, Edwards still had the faster car for the final two laps of overtime due to two fresh tires. If he reaches the summertime without a race victory and making the Chase is bearing down on him, he might be looking back on this desert race feeling like he was Wiley Coyote to Harvick's Road Runner.

Harvick gained entry to the postseason Chase, became the fourth different winner in four races and his Stewart-Haas Racing team became the fourth different team in victory lane this year.

Harvick is nicknamed Happy for three reasons. First, it's pretty obvious when he's happy. And, it's also obvious when he's not. Often, he's just plain stoic. After winning his fifth race at Phoenix in six starts by not much more than a front splitter, Harvick was relieved as much as anything, describing himself as "lucky as hell."

He's supposed to win on the mile oval where he has eight victories, four of them with Stewart-Haas. Harvick's only loss at Phoenix in the last six races occurred last fall when Dale Earnhardt Jr. took a rain-shortened victory, which turned into an upside down Happy day.

"I know that you leave here and you don't win, you're disappointed," said Harvick of the expectations he has coming into the desert mile. "We had the rain situation last time, and we were all fairly distraught over the situation and not winning the race. It's a pressured situation that when you come here, your team and your guys and yourself, you expect to be in contention to win the race, but sometimes circumstances dictate exactly what happens at the end of the race."

Would Harvick have been more aggressive had he been the overtaking driver instead of Edwards?

"I don't think there's any real love lost between the two of us," he said. "You know, I knew that I was going to get hit, and I'm going to hit him in the same type of manner, just for the fact that I don't want to spin him out. But you definitely want to rough him up because that's not the guy that I want to lose to, and I know he doesn't want to lose to me."

So these two guys are not chummy, although they did have an amicable conversation after the race. One of those where the winner swears on a stack of metaphorical bibles he would have done the same thing as the loser.

[to top of second column]

Did the race fan who wants to see "win at all costs" and fists flailing at race's end get short-changed? It's hard to argue against a finish decided by 0.010 seconds and contact on three occasions en route to the checkered flag. In the end, the longtime leader who almost got caught out by a late caution was able to hold the lead despite guys pitting behind him for fresh rubber. (If leader Harvick had pitted, of course, several others, including Edwards, would have stayed out and Harvick would have lost too much track position to make it back to the front.)

Had Edwards hit Harvick harder and gotten the Stewart-Haas Chevy cockeyed in Turn 3, then Harvick couldn't have retaliated and Edwards might have gained the several inches he needed.

As it was, Harvick was masterful on defense.

"I was fully expecting everything that I got," said Harvick, "but I just needed to be able to get knocked up the track far enough to be able to put the throttle back down. Maybe a little bit too defensive. I missed the bottom with the way that the rubber had built up on the racetrack, it just kind of walked up the track and he was able to hold the bottom and able to get to the left rear.

"I felt like I got back to the throttle even soon enough to be able to hold him off," continued Harvick, "but I was kind of a couple feet behind and was able to kind of scrub against his door a little bit to slow him back down. And by the time he'd realized that he was going to be behind, we had carried the momentum by him and we were at the start-finish line."

The incident was a far cry from Joey Logano ramming Matt Kenseth at 200 mph in the race in Kansas last fall with the checkers looming. That left Kenseth no chance to retaliate - until he took Logano's Ford into the fence at Martinsville, Va. two races later.

NASCAR officials made no move to penalize Logano for the Kansas incident, sending a clear message it's OK for a trailing car to take out a slower leader by force. History also says if the faster guy reaches your rear bumper, all bets are off, although 200 mph is a little high for ramming speed. Of course, it's easy to reach your opponent's rear bumper if you use it as a brake...


In Phoenix, Edwards elected a more nuanced path at relatively slower speeds.

Given the "comers and goers" occasioned by the new low downforce package and softer tires from Goodyear, there'll be opportunity enough for more substantive passionate disagreements as the season progresses. And odds are that if Edwards is involved, he'll be far less likely to leave matters to chance or subtle about the laying on of fenders.

[© 2016 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.]

Copyright 2016 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Back to top