Clinton's bout of pneumonia raises
worries for Democrats
Send a link to a friend
[September 12, 2016]
By Steve Holland and Alana Wise
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Democrat Hillary
Clinton's bout of pneumonia, kept secret until she nearly collapsed on
Sunday, has raised an element of uncertainty about her health going into
the final weeks of presidential campaigning and risks feeding a
narrative from rival Donald Trump about her stamina.
The Clinton campaign was forced to admit on Sunday that the 68-year-old
Democratic presidential nominee had been diagnosed with pneumonia on
Friday after she complained of allergies and was seen coughing
repeatedly in recent days.
The pneumonia disclosure was made public hours after her campaign said
she had become "overheated" to explain why, knees buckling and unsteady,
she was rushed from a ceremony marking the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in
Democratic donor and fundraiser Bill Bartmann later fielded calls from
about half a dozen Democrats worried about how the episode would look.
The callers, he said, decided to wait and see how everything plays out.
For Democrats, the incident also brought up some familiar concerns about
Clinton's penchant for secrecy during an ongoing debate about her use of
a private email server while serving as President Barack Obama's
secretary of state from 2009 to 2013.
"You’ve got Donald Trump promoting health conspiracy theories to begin
with, so any time something even lends an air of credence to that
conspiracy, it needs to be debunked right away,” Democratic strategist
Bud Jackson said.
The issue also put pressure on both Clinton and Trump, the Republican
presidential nominee, to reassure American voters about their health
given the rigors of the presidential campaign, in which the food is
often unhealthy, sleep is elusive and the packed schedule and extensive
travel is stressful.
"The short term turbulence will be more about the handling of this than
the substance, though I'm sure both candidates will be pressed for
greater disclosure of health records," said David Axelrod, a former
adviser to President Barack Obama.
Late on Sunday, her campaign canceled Clinton's trip to California
scheduled for Monday morning.
The health problem was the latest blow for Clinton at a time when Trump
has erased most of her lead in national opinion polls and is competitive
again in many battleground states where the Nov. 8 election is likely to
Her dismissal of half of Trump's supporters as a "basket of deplorables"
of racist, homophobic people on Friday triggered a firestorm of
criticism and prompted her to roll back the comment.
During the Republican primary campaign Trump dispatched rival Jeb Bush
by deriding him as a "low energy" candidate. His efforts to raise
questions about Clinton's stamina mirror that strategy.
'IT WILL BE USED, ABSOLUTELY'
Trump aides did not immediately respond to questions about whether Trump
would seek to use the Clinton health incident to his advantage. Trump,
normally voluble on Twitter, stayed silent on the issue on Sunday.
"I expect they will milk it like crazy," Republican strategist Art
Hackney said of the Trump campaign. "He certainly has already indicated
that she doesn’t have the stamina, so I think it will be used,
Trump is expected to discuss his own health regimen in an interview to
air on Thursday with celebrity physician Dr. Mehmet Oz.
[to top of second column]
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton leaves her
daughter Chelsea's home in New York, New York, United States
September 11, 2016, after Clinton left ceremonies commemorating the
15th anniversary of the September 11 attacks feeling "overheated."
Trump, a 70-year-old New York businessman, has made no secret of his
affinity for fast food, sometimes sharing photos of himself on his
campaign jet or at Trump Tower enjoying fried chicken, hamburgers
and a taco bowl.
He has made less information available about his health than Clinton
has. Last December, he released a statement from his doctor, Harold
Bornstein, that described him in excellent health with
"extraordinary" strength and stamina.
The statement did not mention what medicine Trump might be on or
other details typically included in such disclosures and was
dramatically different from the hundreds of pages of medical records
released by Republican nominee John McCain in 2008 to reassure
Americans about his bouts of skin cancer.
“If elected, Mr. Trump, I can state unequivocally, will be the
healthiest individual ever elected to the presidency,” Bornstein
wrote. The Manhattan physician said in August he wrote the letter in
five minutes as a Trump limo waited to pick it up.
Clinton released a two-page letter outlining her medical condition
in July 2015 that sought to reassure Americans about her health
after she fell and suffered a concussion at home in 2012 near the
end of her tenure at the State Department.
Dr. Amesh Adalja, an infectious disease expert and senior associate
at the UPMC Center for Health Security in Pittsburgh who is not
treating Clinton, said recovery from pneumonia can vary from about a
week to longer, depending on the severity.
"Some patients have very little difficulties with activities of
daily living and are only mildly hampered by it while others may
require hospitalization and have to reduce their activities," he
said, adding that pneumonia was the 8th leading cause of death in
the United States.
Clinton's campaign is likely to be pressed on why she did not make
her pneumonia diagnosis public until late Sunday afternoon despite
receiving it two days earlier.
"I think it's exceedingly important that Hillary Clinton be
transparent about what’s going on," said presidential historian
Douglas Brinkley. "If she gets a report of pneumonia on Friday, they
should try to tell the public in real time. The danger for a
candidate is if they seem to be hiding their health history."
(Additional reporting by Amanda Becker in Chappaqua, New York,
Luciana Lopez in New York and Emily Stephenson, Richard Cowan and
Jeff Mason in Washington; Editing by Caren Bohan, Peter Cooney and
[© 2016 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2016 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.