Trade groups call on U.S. to investigate
CSX rail disruptions
Send a link to a friend
[August 16, 2017]
By Eric M. Johnson
(Reuters) - Dozens of U.S. trade groups
have asked federal rail regulators to investigate CSX Corp's <CSX.O>
"chronic service failures," saying problems at No. 3 U.S. railroad have
rippled across the North American rail network, according to a letter
seen by Reuters.
The letter, from the Rail Customer Coalition sent on Monday, is the
latest challenge to CSX Chief Executive Hunter Harrison's effort to ramp
up productivity at the Jacksonville, Florida-based railroad and fulfill
investor expectations for substantially better financial performance.
The 44 trade groups, representing chemical and agricultural companies,
steel and auto makers, and beer producers and importers, among other
companies, told U.S. lawmakers on House and Senate Transportation
committees "chronic service failures" could degrade the nation's broader
"This has put rail dependent business operations throughout the U.S. at
risk of shutting down, caused severe bottlenecks in the delivery of key
goods and services, and has put the health of our nation's economy in
jeopardy," they said.
The shipper groups want Congress to make it easier for them to file
complaints and allow other operators to use CSX track during service
disruptions, according to their letter.
A spokeswoman for Representative Peter DeFazio from Oregon said his
office received the letter and is "continuing to monitor the situation."
The other lawmakers to whom the letter was sent - U.S. Senators John
Thune of South Dakota and Bill Nelson from Florida, and Representative
Bill Shuster of Pennsylvania - did not immediately respond to requests
for comment. Nor did the Surface Transportation Board.
CSX spokesman Rob Doolittle said the company has acknowledged that some
customers are experiencing service issues as Harrison implements his
vision for driving efficiency, known as Precision Scheduled Railroading.
The letter comes about two weeks after the Surface Transportation Board
notified Harrison of complaints about CSX's service. And an analyst
survey last month found shippers have moved freight to rival Norfolk
Southern Corp <NSC.N> and truckers.
CSX's service problems were exacerbated by an Aug 2 derailment in rural
western Pennsylvania that forced the company to re-route trains. Federal
safety officials are investigating the cause of the accident.
The recent issues have caused some investors to sell since the stock hit
a 52-week high of $55.48 on July 13. The stock is off about 10 percent
since news of CSX problems came to light in July.
Jason Seidl, an analyst at Cowen & Co, said the problems at CSX were
bound to improve with time.
"We have seen railroads be in far worse position and recover," Seidl
BUMPS IN THE ROAD
Harrison apologized to customers in a July 31 letter for service
disruptions since he took the job as CEO in March, and assigned blame to
a few employees who have "pushed back."
When asked about customer reactions during CSX's quarterly earnings call
earlier this month, Harrison said, "I don't know, frankly, how to get
there without some bumps in the road."
[to top of second column]
A CSX coal train (R) moves past an idling CSX engine at the
switchyard in Brunswick, Maryland October 16, 2012. REUTERS/Gary
The Rail Customer Coalition's letter echoes complaints from current
and former employees and union officials who told Reuters that job
cuts and changes to operating procedures are disrupting service.
Shippers and employee sources said Harrison's changes and cuts are
causing rail cars and trains to sit idle or be re-routed across
multiple states, delaying product shipments, and leading to
inadequate customer service.
In one Aug. 3 email seen by Reuters, a CSX division manager in
Florida said Crowley Maritime Corporation hauled 150 container loads
by truck from Charlotte, North Carolina, to Jacksonville, Florida,
and then loaded them onto Florida East Coast Railway trains to avoid
CSX's system issues.
A Crowley spokesman declined to comment.
CSX's Doolittle declined to discuss the Florida incident. Regarding
the broader complaints being raised, Doolittle said, "Ultimately the
changes we are making will enable better service to customers."
Data from the Association of American Railroads (AAR) shows CSX
weekly rail car dwell times - the average time a car sits at a
terminal - have crept up to 29.4 hours through the week of August 4,
the last available, versus 26.2 hours for the same week last year.
Train speeds dropped to 18.7 mph versus 20.7 mph for the same
Current and former CSX employees say the railroad is suffering from
poor communication from leadership, job cuts, and rapid changes to
operations - like doubling train sizes, shutting hump yards where
train cars are sorted, increasing the frequency of crew changes on a
service line, and blocking overtime pay.
In Montgomery, Alabama, dwell times jumped to 60.9 hours from 35.8
hours a year earlier, and doubled in Nashville, Tennessee, to 71.9
hours. However, some of CSX's cost-cutting moves do not appear to be
dramatically affecting operating performance in other locations,
based on data CSX provides to the AAR.
At CSX's Barr Yard in Chicago, roughly seven managers now run the
company's service line, down from more than 35 managers a month ago,
an employee told Reuters. The overall work force has been halved by
furloughs, he said.
Even so, weekly dwell times in Chicago have risen and fallen by
several hours over the past month, and were basically unchanged from
a year ago, federal data shows.
Doolittle, the CSX spokesman, declined to discuss the situation in
(Additional reporting by Nick Carey in Detroit, Allison Lampert in
Montreal and Michael Flaherty in New York; editing by Joe White and
[© 2017 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2017 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.