Airbus agrees to settle corruption probes with France,
Send a link to a friend
[January 28, 2020] By
Sudip Kar-Gupta and Tim Hepher
(Reuters) - Airbus <AIR.PA> faces billions
of dollars of fines after agreeing in principle to a settlement with
French, British and U.S. authorities following a crippling three-year
investigation into allegations of bribery and corruption.
A settlement would allow it to avoid criminal charges which, if proven,
could have led to the company being disbarred from public contracts in
the United States and European Union - a massive setback for one of
Europe's top defense and space firms.
The European planemaker has been investigated by French and British
authorities for suspected corruption over jet sales dating back over a
decade. It has also faced U.S. investigations over suspected violations
of export controls.
Announcing the agreement, Airbus - which dominates with U.S. rival
Boeing <BA.N> the commercial airliner market - said it could not comment
on the size of settlements, which still need court approval.
Press reports cited a figure of around 3 billion euros ($3.3 billion),
while some industry analysts have suggested sums as high as 5 billion
euros, dwarfing a previous settlement by aero-engine maker Rolls-Royce <RR.L>
over the use of middlemen.
One person who has closely followed the case estimated the settlement
would be three to four times the $809 million paid by Rolls-Royce in a
deal with U.S., UK and Brazilian agencies in 2017.
Airbus shares rose, however, as traders welcomed the closure of one of
the most damaging chapters in the company's 40-year history. The stock
was up about 1.3% at 1100 GMT.
"Sorting out the fraud investigation is likely to remove a major
overhang for the company," said Vertical Research Partners analyst Rob
British and French investigations began after Airbus drew the attention
of regulators to misleading and incomplete declarations it had made to
Britainís export credit finance agency over payments to sales agents.
Britain's Serious Fraud Office (SFO) launched its probe in August 2016,
followed seven months later by France's Parquet National Financier (PNF).
It was not immediately clear to what extent the U.S. part of any
settlement would stick to the separate issue of export control
violations or include the broader corruption case.
The U.S. Department of Justice has signaled a close interest in the
bribery affair while mainly allowing Britain's SFO to take the lead,
according to people familiar with the matter.
Nor was it clear whether a deal would lead to individual prosecutions,
which are not covered by corporate plea deals.
[to top of second column]
An Airbus A350 takes off at the aircraft builder's headquarters in
Colomiers near Toulouse, France, September 27, 2019. REUTERS/Regis
At the center of the case was a decades-old system of third-party sales
agents run from a now-disbanded headquarters unit which at its height
involved some 250 people in parts of the world and several hundreds of
millions of euros of payments a year, sources familiar with the matter
In 2014, then finance director Harald Wilhelm ordered a halt to all
third-party payments, triggering a massive internal probe and claims
from unpaid consultants.
The investigation, which racked up legal bills of around 100 million
euros a year, led to a board-driven clearout of the company's top
management and plunged the company into years of self-examination,
hampering its sales efforts.
Nobody has been accused of wrongdoing but Airbus acted to clear out its
senior ranks to improve its chances of winning a U.S.-style deferred
prosecution agreement (DPA), insiders said.
In a landmark 2017 ruling setting the bar for future settlements, a
British judge had described Rolls-Royce as "dramatically changed" with a
new leadership and culture.
Airbus has fired more than 100 people over ethics and compliance issues
as a result of its own probe into the allegations, which widened to
But the internal probe led to anger within the Franco-German firm and
its jetliner sales teams who said they had no influence over the tightly
controlled agent system, insiders said.
It also threatened to reopen Franco-German tensions over Airbus as
French sources complained the row diverted attention from a separate
probe into fighter jet dealings with Austria, partially overseen by
German-born Tom Enders who later served as chief executive. Enders has
denied any wrongdoing.
A further German probe into potential misuse of client documents is
(Additional reporting by Kirstin Ridley; editing by Jason Neely and Mark
[© 2020 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2020 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.