DENVER (Reuters) - A state judge struck
down Colorado's gay marriage ban on Wednesday, saying the prohibition
violated constitutional rights, but put his ruling on hold pending
appeal.
It was the latest of several decisions by state and federal judges
to strike down state bans on same-sex nuptials and then stay their
rulings pending challenges to higher courts.
Adams County District Court Judge C. Scott Crabtree said in his
decision that Colorado's prohibition, approved by voters in 2006,
conflicted with the fundamental right to marry.
"The Court rejects the State's attempt to too narrowly describe the
marital right at issue to the right to marry a person of the same
sex," Crabtree wrote.
There are 19 states, plus the District of Columbia, where same-sex
marriage is now legal. Several other same-sex marriage lawsuits are
moving toward the U.S. Supreme Court.
Two other lawsuits, testing bans in Oklahoma and Virginia, have
already been heard by appeals courts.
The attorney general of neighboring Utah said on Wednesday he would
appeal directly to the Supreme Court a ruling by a federal appeals
court last month that backed gay marriage in the conservative,
largely Mormon state.
Responding to Crabtree's ruling, Colorado Attorney General John
Suthers said it reaffirmed the fact that the fate of the state's
same-sex marriage law now rested with the Supreme Court.
"Judge Crabtree provides additional clarity that until the high
court rules on the issue of same-sex marriage, Colorado’s current
laws remain in place," Suthers, a Republican, said in a statement.
'FINAL RESOLUTION'
"Adherence to the rule of law will bring about the final resolution
with the greatest certainty and legal legitimacy," Suthers added.
He has sued the elected county clerk in Boulder, Colorado, after she
issued more than 100 marriage licenses to gay couples following the
ruling on Utah by the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
On Wednesday, Boulder County District Court Judge Andrew Hartman
held a hearing in the case in which an attorney for the state
accused the clerk, Hillary Hall, of flouting the law.
Assistant Solicitor General Michael Francisco said the state's 63
other county clerks had abided by the appellate court's ruling
putting its decision on hold.
"Clerk Hall is the only outlier," he said.
Hall testified briefly, repeating her stance that she could not deny
same-sex couples their fundamental right to marry.
Three lesbians also described the difficulties gay couples face in
Colorado because of the ban, including in areas such as making
medical decisions for partners, getting approval to adopt children,
and being denied federal benefits.
The question of whether the licenses issued by Hall are valid will
be litigated separately.
Outside the building, gay marriage supporters waved signs reading:
"Legalize Love" and "Support Equality."
Hartman said he would rule on the issue "very shortly," but gave no
indication when that might be.
(Reporting by Keith Coffman; Writing by Daniel Wallis; Editing by
Sandra Maler and Peter Cooney)
