|
 In one study, twins had similar brain volume even when one used
recreational marijuana and the other didn’t. But in the second
study, high-risk male teens who used marijuana did have changes in
brain volume.
Experts agree that much remains unknown and the new findings just
“scratch the surface.”
“We do not know nearly enough about effects of cannabis on the
brain, especially the developing brain,” said Dr. David Goldman of
the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism in Rockville,
Maryland, in email to Reuters Health.
For the twin study, researchers used interview and neuroimaging data
collected between 2012 and 2014 from 71 pairs of young adult twins
or siblings who had never used cannabis, 81 pairs who had both used
cannabis at one point, and 89 pairs where one reported using
cannabis and the other did not.
On the whole, those who reported ever using cannabis tended to have
smaller volumes in certain areas of the brain, including the left
amygdala and right ventral striatum, which are involved with
emotions and reward, compared to those who had not used, but all
were within the range of normal variation.
These differences seemed to be due to genetic or environmental
variation, not to a causal role of marijuana in changing the brain,
the authors wrote.
“Some have argued that cannabis use, particularly chronic use which
we did not specifically study, might induce these morphological
changes,” said senior author Arpana Agrawal of Washington University
in St. Louis.
“We provide an alternate explanation,” Agrawal told Reuters Health
by email. “In our study, even those who did not ever use cannabis
had lower amygdala volumes if their brother or sister had used
cannabis, suggesting that predisposing factors that siblings share
contribute to the link between cannabis use and lower amygdala
volume.”
Twins with mismatched cannabis use histories did not appear to have
differences in brain volume.
For the second study, researchers investigated the connection
between cannabis use and schizophrenia in more than 1,500
adolescents and young adults at high risk for the condition.
More than half the participants were male. All were between the ages
of 12 and 21 and in all of them, genetic testing had been done to
assess their risk for schizophrenia.
Male participants with a high genetic risk for schizophrenia who
reported using marijuana before age 16 had less thickness of the
layers of the cerebral cortex than non-users.
Cortical thickness indicates “how ‘bushy’ the cells are, how many
branches they have, how good they might be at processing
information,” said senior author Dr. Tomas Paus of the Rotman
Research Institute in Toronto. But this study did not test thinking
ability or other actual clinical changes.
[to top of second column] |
The researchers did not see any links between marijuana use and
brain volume in low-risk males nor in low or high-risk females.
For certain men with a predisposition to schizophrenia, however,
using cannabis may alter brain development - but this study cannot
prove that smoking marijuana causes changes in the brain, the
authors wrote.
“Something might be going on in the male brain that may make it a
bit more vulnerable,” Paus said.
Boys with higher risk were no more likely to use cannabis than those
with lower risk, so it’s unlikely that they were “self-medicating”
with the drug, told Reuters Health by phone.
In general, the results are useful for researchers, but most people
should not be concerned by them, he said.
“What they should worry about is if mental illness runs in their
family and they started using cannabis early,” Paus said. “Also
remember we don’t know if the differences we see in adolescence get
worse, persist, or disappear,” he said.
Goldman, who wrote an editorial accompanying the new studies, added
in his email, “What this new research shows is that it is also
dangerous to make assumptions about causality from correlation.”
Young cannabis users turn out differently than others, but were
already innately different, either because of genetic factors or
early life experience, he said.
“There are so many different ways to look at the brain, we just
scratch the surface here,” Paus said.
SOURCE: http://bit.ly/1PTGOMY, http://bit.ly/1NI9M3j and http://bit.ly/1WSGvH7
JAMA Psychiatry, online August 26, 2015.
[© 2015 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.] Copyright 2015 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. |
