Lock up the college funds, or it is easy to raid them

[August 25, 2016]  By Beth Pinsker

NEW YORK (Reuters) - If your kids' college savings are not walled off in some kind of separate account, how do you keep yourself from raiding the kitty?

Stephanie Sadural Heincker is one mom who does not trust herself: she has an automatic deduction from each paycheck go into 529 college savings plans for her two- and four-year-old.

Heincker's own parents dipped into the money they had set aside in a savings account for her, so she ended up saddled with a lot of student debt.

"This is the least I can do to try to smooth the path for my kids a little bit," said the 36-year-old from Indianapolis, Indiana.

The number of families saving for college is at an all-time high, according to new data released on Thursday from Fidelity Investments. But a large portion of parents do not keep college savings separate, leaving money earmarked for education vulnerable to emergencies or luxuries.

Since Fidelity started measuring college savings rates in 2007, the number of families who say they are saving has jumped 24 percent, from 58 percent to 72 percent today. But among those who are saving now, only 42 percent use a dedicated savings account, such as a 529 plan.

The reasons for co-mingling savings ranged from simply preferring it that way to confusion about account types to apathy about getting started.

Financial experts offer plenty of cautionary tales about why this matters.

Take one of financial adviser Levi Brandriss' clients from Bethesda, Maryland, who kept the money stashed for college in a savings account, intending to roll it into a 529 plan. The clients stalled because they were concerned about what would happen to the funds if their child did not go to college, or did not need all that they had saved.

In the meantime, they decided to use that money to buy a vacation property.

Vickie Adams, a financial adviser who specializes in divorce issues in Manhattan Beach, California, has had many clients with nebulous chunks of money that were originally supposed to go toward college funds. She said that money always gets divided up and used to pay legal fees and other expenses.

"But when there is a 529 plan, nobody ever thinks of invading that, they are sacrosanct," said Adams.

In 24 years of practice, she has only had one case where a parent went into a dedicated college fund and took out money, and that was a spouse who also committed tax fraud.

ALTERNATIVE INVESTING

Not everyone who shies away from 529 plans and other educational savings plans is doing so out of financial ineptitude.

Some college savers prefer to have more sophisticated investing options than are available in most state 529 plans. Some are seeking lower fees. Some do not want to be locked into only spending the funds on educational expenses. Some eschew the volatility of the stock market.

A graduate wears a houndstooth ribbon on her graduation cap during the University of Alabama commencement ceremony at Coleman Coliseum in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, August 6, 2011, in honor of fellow students who were killed in a devastating April 27, 2011 tornado. REUTERS/Marvin Gentry

One choice for these investors is to consider a Roth IRA as part of their college saving strategy. Contributions can be withdrawn penalty-free after five years, while the growth stays in and continues to build tax-free.

But this is risky for parents if the Roth is part of their own retirement strategy. "It sounds clichéd, you can't borrow for retirement, but you can borrow for college," said Keith Bernhardt, Fidelity's vice president of retirement and college products.

High-net worth families could also consider zero-coupon municipal bonds, said Jonathan Swanburg, a financial adviser for Tri-Star Group in Houston, Texas.

In states like Texas with no income tax, Swanburg's clients often look beyond 529 plans. For those worried about stock market volatility, bonds offer low risk and a comparable return over time, given that most age-based investment plans get more conservative as children get closer to college age. But to make the strategy work, he suggests minimum investments of around $15,000 when a child is born.

"It's not the solution for everyone. This is for where a person says 'I hate volatility and I don't want to pay tax and I want to remain flexible,'" Swanburg said.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, Stephanie Sadural Heincker supplements her 529 plan with a walled-off savings account tied to an app called Qapital (https://www.qapital.com/), which rounds up change from her debit card transactions. It's a few cents at a time, but it makes her feel better.

"Something about the psychology of having that separate account just works," Sadural Heincker said.

(Editing by Lauren Young and Andrew Hay)

[© 2016 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.]

Copyright 2016 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.