|
 Experts questioned the usefulness of the results, however, because
despite the study having recruited more than 40,000 participants
through a TV game show, more than half dropped out.
It’s not clear how interesting these findings are, said Dr. Giovanni
A. Fava of the University of Bologna and the State University of New
York at Buffalo, who was not part of the study.
“First of all, subjects were recruited in a very odd way (a TV
show), there was no actual control for the intervention and the
participation was very low, casting doubts on the entire study
validity,” he said by email.
The researchers advertised the internet-based wellbeing study during
a reality show called Life at Stake in which Finnish celebrities
were trained by coaches to improve their own wellbeing, between 2012
and 2013.
“People were invited to do an electronic health check on program’s
internet site, where they were also offered a possibility to
participate in the intervention,” said lead author Minna Torniainen-Holm
of the National Institute for Health and Welfare and the Institute
for Molecular Medicine Finland FIMM at the University of Helsinki.
More than 73,000 people responded to the ads and more than 42,000
actually began the email-based exercises.
The interventions were based on cognitive behavioral therapy and
positive psychology, intended to increase wellbeing and improve
ability to cope with stress. Participants could choose between
programs targeting interpersonal relationships, like conflict
resolution, or their own lifestyle, like quitting smoking, weight
management or exercise. Both were options on the Electronic Health
and Wellbeing Check and Coaching program, which is commercially
available through health centers and websites in Finland.
Participants were sent 17 emails including a paragraph giving some
background on the health topic chosen, a link to a video on the
“assignment” of the email and instructions for the assignment. They
received two to three emails per week for two months.
Some assignments were designed to promote forgiveness, to let go of
past experiences or to recognize personal coping strategies, among
others.
Participants tracked their progress with periodic questionnaires
answered before the programs began, two months later and again two
years later.
People who chose lifestyle interventions only showed improvement at
the two-month point, with no longer-term changes, compared to people
who filled out the initial questionnaires but did not continue the
programs.
[to top of second column] |
Those who chose interpersonal interventions showed more gratitude
and confidence at the two-month and two-year follow up points,
albeit only small increases, according to the results in BMC
Psychology.
“The effect on their life also appears to depend on how much effort
a person invests on doing the assignments as instructed,” Torniainen-Holm
said.
But less than 17,000 people took part in at least one follow-up
questionnaire, the authors note.
“High dropout rate may reflect the fact that people were not
primarily recruited to participate in a study, but they were invited
to do an electronic health check and to participate on the
trainings,” Torniainen-Holm said.
The new study was not a randomized controlled trial, so it was not
perfect, said Dr. Gavin Andrews, professor of psychiatry at UNSW in
Sydney, Australia, who also was not part of the new study.
“Our field is using automated web based (cognitive behavioral
therapy) courses to help people with anxiety and depressive
disorders, with and without complicating physical disorders, to
recover,” Andrews said. “We have done 25 randomized controlled
trials and it is clear that the benefits are comparable to face to
face therapy, that the benefits last, that the costs are small.”
If general wellbeing did improve, people may have slept better,
eaten better, drank less and been less irritable, he said.
There are similar commercially available programs and phone apps for
English speakers, Andrews told Reuters Health by email. Many apps
are free, while programs with proven results are available for less
than $50 USD, he said.
SOURCE: http://bit.ly/1rU3l62 BMC Psychology, online May 17, 2016.
[© 2016 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.] Copyright 2016 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. |
