Must see TV: why gutting
NAFTA unlikely to create U.S. jobs
Send a link to a friend
[October 25, 2016]
By Timothy Aeppel
CUIDAD
JUAREZ, MEXICO (Reuters) - Both U.S. presidential candidates routinely
criticize free-trade deals they blame for the loss of American jobs.
But tweaking the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), as Hillary
Clinton has pledged to do, or ripping it up, as Donald Trump demands,
may do nothing to help companies like Element Electronics Corp, which
owns America’s last television factory.
Winnsboro, South Carolina-based Element, and the television industry
more broadly, offer a window into the complexity of industrial supply
chains and illustrate why pushing manufacturing jobs back to the United
States is so difficult.
Element's plant in South Carolina is nearly identical to a rival factory
operated by Taiwanese conglomerate Tatung Company that sits on a dusty
back street in this Mexican border town. Both import nearly all their
components from Asia. The parts often flow in through the same southern
California ports.
But there's a big, and costly, difference. The Mexican plant, by sitting
just over the border from El Paso, Texas, doesn't have to pay duty on
those parts, even when the finished televisions are sold in the United
States. But Element's factory has to foot the tariff bill, which makes
its televisions more expensive.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2016/Oct/25/images/ads/current/graue_sda_june2015.png)
"It's pretty crazy that I'm disadvantaged for using U.S. labor," says
Michael O'Shaughnessy, Element’s president.
That's a sentiment that Trump, the Republican nominee, has forcefully
tapped as he makes the case that radically revamping the trade deal
would level the playing field and bring jobs back. Many trade experts,
though, say it would be a costly disaster to try to unravel these
production networks, which essentially treat Mexico as a 51st state.
The Peterson Institute for International Economics, a Washington think
tank that favors free trade, released a study last month that predicted
imposing stiff tariffs on Mexico and China would disrupt North American
producers that have created global supply chains and push the United
States into a recession.
"The TV industry is characterized by particularly dense webs of
cross-border supply chains with Mexico and China," says Marcus Noland,
the economist who directed the study. "There'd be chaos and a trade
war."
Even many who oppose NAFTA acknowledge it would be disruptive to
suddenly erect barriers, given the way companies have shifted supply
chains to integrate Mexico.
NAFTA'S LEGACY
NAFTA, implemented in 1994, forged a common market between the United
States, Mexico and Canada. In response, many industries, including
television manufactures, have transformed themselves by creating supply
chains that crisscross the border.
Televisions once were produced in the United States and elsewhere with
hundreds of parts, often tucked into elaborate wooden cases. A modern
flat screen, by contrast, has relatively few parts, and more than 70
percent of its value is packed into the glass and the electronics
integrated directly into the panel.
The heart of the industry, including that core glass technology and
production, is now based in Asia.
About half of all TVs imported to the U.S. come from Mexico, says Paul
Gagnon, an expert on the industry's supply chain at IHS Markit, an
economic research firm.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2016/Oct/25/images/ads/current/ldn_sda_062409.png)
"The main reason for that is so the producers can respond quickly to
fluctuations in demand," he says. TV sales are highly seasonal, spiking
late in the year. In Mexico, some of the factories double their
workforce for just a few months to respond to this.
Gagnon doubts the jobs would come back to the United States, because
margins on TVs are so low. "If there were any major cost increase (in
Mexico), you'd probably see some shift to Asia for production -- rather
than seeing that production happen in the U.S."
Some Mexican plants mold the plastic casing and do other tasks in the
assembly process. But in many cases -- including at both the Element and
Tatung plants -- the assembly plants do mostly finishing touches like
inserting printing circuit boards and tuning the units. This creates
relatively few jobs compared to the kind of television manufacturing
done in the U.S. industry's heyday.
In the 1950s, there were some 150 domestic television manufacturers in
the United States, and employment peaked at about 100,000 in the 1960s.
[to top of second column] |
![](../images/102516pics/busine25.jpg)
Republican U.S. presidential nominee Donald Trump speaks as
Democratic U.S. presidential nominee Hillary Clinton listens during
their third and final 2016 presidential campaign debate at UNLV in
Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S., October 19, 2016. REUTERS/Mark Ralston/Pool
![](../images/ads/current/demay_inv-lda081412.png)
Mexico's cost advantage over the United State is formidable. O’Shaughnessy said
he pays his 200 workers, who operate in a converted shirt factory, about $15 an
hour. The pay at the Juarez plant is about $2.50 an hour.
Even with this edge, it's getting harder to do the work in Mexico, said Chan-hsing
Diao, manager of the Tatung plant. (Tatung doesn't sell televisions under its
own name, but rather is paid by other manufacturers to assemble their name-brand
products.)
"The industry is consolidating and the cost pressures are enormous," he said,
noting that over the last six years, the amount he is paid to assemble a 32-inch
television has fallen by half, from about $6 a unit to $3 a unit.
"The profits are this," he said, holding up two fingers almost touching.
The
Tatung plant in Juarez occupies a cavernous space that was once a windshield
factory. It now features long assembly lines for televisions and produced 15
million TVs over the last seven years, Diao said. Some 13 million of those were
sold in the United States.
In January, the company lost its main customer, a Chinese TV manufacturer that
Diao declined to identify. Tatung is scrambling to find a new manufacturer that
wants to build TVs for the United States. In the meantime, it continues
assembling TVs for Mexico and some other Latin American markets.
Diao
warned there would be a trade war if a new U.S. administration tore up the NAFTA
agreement. With profits already so tight in Mexico, many Chinese producers might
find it easier to ship finished goods directly from Asia rather than move
production and jobs to the United States, he said.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2016/Oct/25/images/ads/current/bennett_lda_123015.png)
IN SEARCH OF AN EXEMPTION
O'Shaughnessy, for his part, said he just wants to get the same break on import
duties as Mexico gets under NAFTA. His decision to build in the United States,
he said, was driven entirely by his only customer for the U.S. plant, Wal-Mart,
which uses Element as a centerpiece of its campaign to promote domestic
manufacturing. The South Carolina TVs are shipped in boxes emblazoned with
American flags and bearing the words "Assembled in the USA."
O'Shaughnessy has appealed for a tariff exemption from his local congressman,
Rep. Mick Mulvaney, a Republican. Mulvaney said he is sympathetic but has been
unable to win over many fellow lawmakers who consider special exemptions a form
of earmarks for special interests, which many oppose on principle.
"Element makes clear the real world implications of these trade deals we have
signed," said Mulvaney, adding that it's time to "review" NAFTA to iron out this
and other loopholes.
Back in Juarez, the annual ramp-up of hiring is under way at the Tatung plant to
supply the surge of televisions bought over the holidays. Employment at Tatung
goes as low as 280 each year, for instance, but is now on its way up to 600,
Diao said.
"You could never do that in America — at least not easily," he says, referring
to this cycle of hiring and firing large numbers.
(Editing by Eric Effron and Edward Tobin)
[© 2016 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.] Copyright 2016 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2016/Oct/25/images/ads/current/cca_laptop-sda021709.png) |