Juror in Oregon militia conspiracy trial
dismissed over bias
Send a link to a friend
[October 27, 2016]
By Scott Bransford
PORTLAND, Ore. (Reuters) - A federal judge
in the conspiracy trial of seven people who took part in the armed
occupation of a U.S. wildlife center in Oregon dismissed a juror over
questions of bias on Wednesday, then ordered jury deliberations to begin
anew with a replacement.
"It's a new jury, a new day, a new start," U.S. District Judge Anna
Brown said as she directed an alternate to step in for the disqualified
juror, stressing that the reconstituted panel must renew its
consideration of the case from scratch.
"They cannot pick up where they left off," she said.
The jury's impartiality came under scrutiny on Tuesday, on day three of
deliberations, when the panel sent a handwritten note to the judge
stating that one juror had professed to being "very biased" at the
outset of the jury sessions last week.
According to the letter, a copy of which defense lawyers showed
journalists, the juror cited his past employment with the federal Bureau
of Land Management, or BLM, although it left unclear whether his
supposed bias was for or against the government.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2016/Aug/26/images/ads/current/best_friends_sda_120215.png)
Brown questioned the juror privately on Tuesday and said afterward she
found "no basis" for concluding he was biased.
But defense lawyers said they were not convinced, and filed a motion on
Wednesday calling for a mistrial unless the judge agreed to dismiss the
juror in question and restart deliberations with an alternate in his
place.
The judge agreed to remove the juror on Wednesday, saying she had no
recourse despite finding no verified prejudice or wrongdoing. Brown said
opening the jury to further interrogation on the matter would have
risked undermining the requisite confidentiality of its deliberations.
The dismissed juror's history as a BLM employee 20 years ago was first
disclosed during jury selection. But neither side made an issue of it
then, even though the defendants' antagonism toward the government,
particularly the BLM, was at the heart of the case.
The defendants contend their seizure of the Malheur National Wildlife
Refuge in eastern Oregon was a legitimate act of civil disobedience
protesting control over millions of acres of public land in the West by
various federal agencies, including the BLM.
The government has accused the leader of the occupation, Ammon Bundy,
and his six followers on trial of engaging in a lawless scheme to seize
federal property by force during the 41-day standoff that began in early
January.
[to top of second column] |
![](../images/102716PICS/news_d9.jpg)
Anti-militia supporters demonstrate outside the Harney County
Courthouse in Burns, Oregon, U.S. on February 1, 2016. REUTERS/Jim
Urquhart/File Photo
![](../images/ads/current/richardson_lda_090916.png)
The standoff led to the shooting death of one protester by police
and left millions of dollars in damage to the refuge, much of it
from bunkers and trenches built by the heavily armed occupiers.
The six men and one woman on trial are charged with conspiracy to
impede federal officers through intimidation, threats or force, as
well as possession of firearms in a federal facility and theft of
government property.
Each faces up to six years in prison if convicted of conspiracy
alone.
One of Bundy's attorneys, J. Morgan Philpot, said he was satisfied
with the judge's decision, adding he believed the integrity of the
trial had been preserved.
"I don't think anybody wants a mistrial," Philpot said. "I don't
think anything tends to indicate a taint in the jury at this time."
The 12 jurors were excused for the rest of the day and were to
return on Thursday for further instructions. It remained unclear
when deliberations would resume.
(Writing by Steve Gorman; Editing by Toni Reinhold and Peter Cooney)
[© 2016 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.]
Copyright 2016 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2016/Oct/27/images/ads/current/dd_spec_BD_lda_wpic_2016.png)
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2016/Aug/26/images/ads/current/directory_buttons.png) |