|
 The ANFFA union renewed its longstanding criticism about budget cuts
and understaffing after the United States blocked Brazilian fresh
beef shipments late last week, saying it found abscesses in the meat
and signs of systemic failure of inspections.
The ban, twinned with the disclosure that the European Union had
found E.coli and salmonella in meat and chicken exported from
Brazil, was the latest black eye for a key sector of the country's
sprawling farm economy.
ANFFA President Mauricio Porto said in an interview that the
country's inspector staffing had slid to 2,600 from 3,200 in 2002,
even as the number of meatpacking plants more than doubled.
While it is not atypical for government unions to grouse about
budget cuts that thin their own ranks, the inspectors' criticism has
taken on an added resonance given the export woes, which come on top
of a meat oversight bribery scandal that rocked the sector in March.
"This could get worse, because more than half of current inspectors
have enough working time to retire, and they are likely to do it to
be able to get better retirement terms before the new pension code
is approved," Porto said, referring to a proposed pension reform
that is a central goal of President Michel Temer's administration.
The Agriculture Ministry was aware of the criticism by the union, a
spokeswoman said, but did not have any immediate additional comment.
Brazil’s government in March announced a 45 percent cut in the
Agriculture Ministry’s budget, part of a plan to reduce spending as
it fights a fiscal deficit that reached record levels in the last
two years.
Brazilian Deputy Agriculture Minister Eumar Novacki on Friday said
the abscesses U.S. inspectors found in the Brazilian meat did not
represent a public health risk, adding that some cattle had
experienced adverse reactions to vaccines to prevent foot-and-mouth
disease.
He acknowledged there were flaws in Brazil's inspection system but
said there could also be "commercial motivations" for the import
ban.
[to top of second column] |
The Agricultural Ministry's linkage of the abscesses to vaccines was
questioned by some experts. Vaccines for foot-and-mouth disease are
the No. 1 vaccines used in animals worldwide, said James Roth,
director of the Center for Food Security and Public Health at Iowa
State University.
In Brazil, drug companies including Merck & Co and Bayer Animal
Health are approved to sell vaccines for the disease, according to
the center.
Roth said “any injection into an animal might rarely produce an
abscess” if the needle is dirty. However, "if abscesses are showing
up in the meat, there has to be a failure in the slaughter plant
because those should be caught and removed,” he said.
The USDA had no immediate comment on whether foot-and-mouth vaccines
or budget cuts have contributed to problems with Brazil’s fresh
beef.
The U.S. ban on Brazilian meat came three months after a broader
crisis caused by a police investigation into alleged bribery of
health officials by meatpackers including JBS SA, the world's
largest protein processor.
The union said the understaffing situation was also contributing to
corruption since it is harder to bribe employees who work in tandem.
While only the United States put in place an outright ban on fresh
beef from Brazil, officials in Canada and the EU said on Friday they
had rejected some shipments of Brazilian beef in recent months.
The EU cited issues with Shiga toxin-producing E.coli in beef as
well as salmonella in poultry.
(Reporting by Marcelo Teixeira, additional reporting by Tom Polansek;
Writing by Christian Plumb; Editing by Meredith Mazzilli and David
Gregorio)
[© 2017 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.] Copyright 2017 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
|
