Special Report: Dangerous News - How two
young reporters shook Myanmar
Send a link to a friend
[August 08, 2018]
By Tom Lasseter
(Reuters) YANGON, Myanmar - Late in the
afternoon of Dec. 12 last year, Wa Lone's cell phone rang. It was a man
named Naing Lin, a lance corporal in Myanmar's 8th Security Police
Battalion.
The policeman urged Wa Lone, a 31-year-old reporter with Reuters, to
meet him immediately at the battalion's barracks on the outskirts of
Yangon. Night was falling around the golden spires of the pagodas in
this former capital city.
"He told me that if I don't come now," Wa Lone would later recall in a
Myanmar courtroom, "I might not be able to meet him because he is about
to transfer to another region."
Wa Lone, whose large eyeglasses rest on chubby cheeks, had spent weeks
looking into Battalion 8. He was working on a story about the murder of
10 members of the country's Rohingya Muslim minority during a military
operation in western Rakhine State. And he'd gotten his hands on
explosive material: photographs of the 10 men before and after they were
killed.
One picture showed the men's bodies, hacked and shot to death, in a
shallow grave. Another, taken while they were still alive, showed them
on their knees. In the background, milling around with assault rifles,
were members of Battalion 8.
Before going to meet the lance corporal, Wa Lone checked in with the
Reuters bureau chief, Antoni Slodkowski, who told him to take another
reporter along. That man, 27-year-old Kyaw Soe Oo, was visiting from
Rakhine State and had recently been hired by the news agency.
Setting out at about 6 p.m., the bureau's white Nissan SUV crossed an
overpass that overlooks Inya Lake, ringed by homes of Myanmar's elite,
including the nation's de facto leader, Nobel Peace Prize laureate Aung
San Suu Kyi. It was a world beyond the reach of Wa Lone, the son of a
rice farmer from a village of a few hundred people.
About halfway to the Battalion 8 compound, the SUV was stuck in traffic.
Wa Lone later remembered feeling uneasy: Why had the policeman insisted
on him coming right away? The reporters discussed turning around. But
they decided to push on.
Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo made it to the entrance of Battalion 8 around 8
p.m. After meeting Lance Corporal Naing Lin and a second policeman, the
reporters said in court, they went with the cops down the street to an
open-air beer garden. The men ordered beer and fish crackers. They
talked about Rakhine State, Naing Lin recalled in court testimony. He
told the reporters about coming under attack by Rohingya insurgents on
Aug. 25 last year, as the militants launched a series of assaults on
police stations.
When it was time to go, Wa Lone later said in court, Naing Lin handed
him a copy of the Myanmar Alin, a state-run newspaper, rolled up with
some documents inside. As the two reporters left the restaurant, they
were surrounded by men in civilian clothes. "These are secret
documents!" Wa Lone recalled one man shouting. A pair of handcuffs was
slapped on Wa Lone's wrists, and another on Kyaw Soe Oo's. They were
then pulled into two parked cars.
Naing Lin recalls the encounter differently. He testified in court that
Wa Lone called him on Dec. 12 to request a meeting, and that when he met
the two reporters at the beer garden, he came alone. He also denied
giving Wa Lone any documents.
With their arrest, the two reporters were thrust into the murky
confluence of military and civilian rule in this ethnically fractured
nation of some 50 million people. To dignitaries in Western capitals,
from Pope Francis to former U.S. President Bill Clinton, their
incarceration would become a test of press freedom in Myanmar, and how
far the country has traveled toward a more open society. On July 9, a
judge charged the two under the Official Secrets Act, a law that carries
a maximum sentence of 14 years.
At the beginning of this decade, Myanmar was a focus of hopes for
democratic progress in Southeast Asia, a neighborhood long marked by
strongman regimes. Aung San Suu Kyi was released in 2010 after about 15
years of house arrest under a military government. In 2015, her party
swept general elections.
For the youth of Myanmar, like Wa Lone, that sharp turn of events
brought a sudden, historically improbable expectation of freedom after
decades of brutal military rule. But the army never fully relinquished
power: In 2008, it put in place a constitution granting itself broad
powers and control of key ministries.
And peace has not come to Myanmar. Deadly ethnic conflicts, obscure to
most of the world but bloody at home, have continued to rumble.
Last year, widespread enmity for the country's best-known ethnic
minority, the Rohingya Muslims, fed a savage military campaign that
forced some 700,000 people to flee their homes for Bangladesh. Now, the
Myanmar army stands accused by United Nations officials of having
committed widespread killings, mass rape and ethnic cleansing. In the
face of this condemnation, Suu Kyi has not uttered a word of public
criticism of the armed forces.
A spokesman for Aung San Suu Kyi, Zaw Htay, and an Army spokesman did
not respond to requests for comment for this article. Zaw Htay has said
that Myanmar's courts are independent and the reporters are receiving a
fair trial. The military has denied its troops took part in ethnic
cleansing in Rakhine State last year.
Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo's reporting on the massacre of the 10 Rohingya
men was published by Reuters in February. The article placed them at
odds with their country's Buddhist majority, to which the reporters,
Aung San Suu Kyi and top military leaders all belong. Much of that
majority despises the Rohingya, viewing them as foreign interlopers from
South Asia. It was groundbreaking investigative journalism in Myanmar.
But to their own people, the reporters' quest for truth was an act of
betrayal.
The pair have been behind bars for almost eight months, most of that
time at Yangon's Insein Prison, a hulking edifice of 19th century
British colonial architecture that has held thousands of political
prisoners, including Aung San Suu Kyi herself for a brief period. And
they have been appearing in court since January, sitting through more
than 30 hearings. A verdict in their trial could be handed down in the
coming weeks.
The story of the two reporters and their roles in Myanmar's experiment
with press freedom is pieced together from their testimony and that of
police at their trial. It also draws on other accounts given by Wa Lone
and Kyaw Soe Oo and interviews with their colleagues, their relatives
and their friends.
The day after their arrest, an order was issued from the office of the
nation's then-president authorizing police to pursue charges against the
two reporters. Then, for two weeks, Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo disappeared
without a trace into the hands of the police.
THE MAKING OF A NON-CONFORMIST
Wa Lone's collision with the state was, in many ways, a long time
coming.
He grew up in a traditional wood clapboard house, built by his
grandfather in the small village of Kin Pyit, with a population of less
than 500. Reached by a skinny dirt road, the village is an island among
outstretched rice paddies.
When Wa Lone was a boy, his father, a rice farmer named Tin Myint,
needed to borrow money before planting. At harvest season, he was forced
to sell a quota of his rice below market price to the local military
administration. "It was not enough, we had to take out loans to plant
the next crop," said Wa Lone's younger brother, Thura Aung.
Money was tight. Meals were usually rice with vegetables, rarely with
the added expense of meat, said Thura Aung.
Wa Lone was unwilling to accept such frustrations, Tin Myint said. "He
was really impatient. He always said, 'Where is the improvement? How are
we going to improve our lives if we keep going like this?'" he said.
Wa Lone traveled to Yangon in 2004, the country's former capital and
still its main city, and got a job in a welding shop. The pay was bad
and he didn't know much about welding. "They treated us like – I
wouldn't say slaves, but something like that," is how Wa Lone describes
the experience.
A few months later, he moved to Mawlamyine, a smaller city about a
six-hour drive from Yangon. It sits near the shores of the Andaman Sea,
and he had an uncle who lived at a neighborhood monastery there.
His mother died of breast cancer at the end of 2005, but Wa Lone didn't
receive word until two months after her death, when a monk from his
village visited the monastery and passed on the news. The first job he
got in Mawlamyine was unloading vegetables at a night market. He was
still a teenager.
While living in the city, Wa Lone and four friends began hanging out
after work at a large monastery down the street from his uncle. It had a
reading room, a project funded by the British Embassy and British
Council to stock libraries with English books in cities across Myanmar.
The group took an English language class for a while, but mostly they
read books and talked.
In 2007, Wa Lone and his friends followed news reports as protests
gripped the nation. Known as the Saffron Revolution, the uprising
included long processions of Buddhist monks taking to the streets in
defiance of the military junta. The junta cracked down, reportedly
killing at least 31 people and arresting thousands.
In 2009, Wa Lone heard about other young people from Myanmar meeting in
Thailand to discuss democracy. He spent more than two months there with
them, talking about political theory and reading books such as George
Orwell's "Animal Farm." Wa Lone watched documentaries about protest
movements – the Orange Revolution in Ukraine, the American Civil Rights
movement, the struggle against apartheid in South Africa.
Wa Lone said he returned to Mawlamyine inspired to do more for the
people of his country. He didn't want to get arrested or confront the
authorities – both, he reasoned, would be bad for his family. He
continued with volunteer work and charity drives to fund monastery
schools.
Around him, the nation's politics were changing. Aung San Suu Kyi was
released in 2010. The military junta installed a quasi-civilian regime
led by ex-generals the next year. The decision by Suu Kyi's party, the
National League for Democracy, to contest by-elections in 2012 was
thrilling, said Kyaw Naing Oo, one of the circle of friends in
Mawlamyine. Now in his mid-thirties, he runs a charity school.
"At the time of the election we really hoped for more freedom because it
was a democratic party," said Kyaw Naing Oo, "and Aung San Suu Kyi is a
democratic icon."
In a monastery where Wa Lone stayed in Mawlamyine, a small house at the
end of an alley, another member of his family recently received
visitors. Aww Bar Sa, who is a monk and Wa Lone's second cousin,
gestured for the reporters to follow him upstairs. A golden Buddha sat
in a shrine, with flashing red, blue and green LED lights all around.
As boys of the same age, Wa Lone and Aww Bar Sa grew up together in Kin
Pyit village. "Since he was young he would argue about whether the world
is round or flat, or whether the world is moving or standing still," Aww
Bar Sa said, laughing at the memories of Wa Lone. "He would argue about
such things. Many in the village did not understand these topics."
Asked about Wa Lone's journalism, Aww Bar Sa grew more solemn.
"The country's development is still slow. People don't have much
knowledge yet. There are still many superstitions," said Aww Bar Sa.
"So, if you don't write from the side of your own religion, they think
of you as a traitor."
That sentiment is evident in the comments posted on a Facebook page set
up by Reuters – "Free Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo" – after the arrests. The
page has photographs of Kyaw Soe Oo, in handcuffs, hugging his
two-year-old daughter. There's Wa Lone beside his pregnant wife, and his
wife without him, crying. Below, visitors posted a string of slurs and
threats.
"They are traitors"
"They are disgusting"
"They should be given the death sentence"
The Rohingya aren't afforded citizenship. Their very ethnicity is not
recognized by Myanmar officialdom. Many of the Rohingya still in the
country live in isolated colonies that are a cross between shanty towns
and internment camps. They are, according to Human Rights Watch, "one of
the largest stateless populations in the world."
"I don't use the word 'Rohingya'," says Aye Chan, a nationalist activist
from Rakhine State who is now promoting the settlement of Buddhists in
the areas where the Rohingya lived before they fled. "They are Bengalis.
They're from Bangladesh."
Aye Chan socialized with Aung San Suu Kyi when both were studying in
Japan in the 1980s, and he himself was jailed for seven years for
supporting democratic reform during the junta era. Seated in the lobby
of Yangon's Lotte Hotel, with a view of Inya Lake outside, he spelled
out his take on the current crisis.
He visited abandoned Muslim villages days after the Rohingya fled, which
he said put him in a position to dispel allegations of mass rape and
other atrocities by Myanmar soldiers. As evidence, he cited meeting with
an officer in the area. "I asked one of the border police, an officer,
'There are accusations about you of raping these women?' He laughed. And
he said: 'These women don't bath even once in a week. How can we sleep
with them?'"
In Aung San Suu Kyi's speeches, she avoids the term "Rohingya" in favor
of "Muslims," a word that denotes religion but not homeland.
Sitting down at a hotel restaurant in the capital city of Naypyitaw, an
aide to Aung San Suu Kyi spoke in support of her.
The situation inside Myanmar, behind closed doors, is more nuanced than
it might appear to outsiders who urge Aung San Suu Kyi to speak out on
behalf of the Rohingya, said Sean Turnell, an Australian academic who
serves as her special economic consultant.
"'Nobel Prize winner overseeing genocide' is a damn good headline, I get
it," he said.
But under the 2008 constitution, the military is "completely beyond the
control of the civilian government," said Turnell. The civilian
government "has no de jure supervision and no de facto supervision. At
all. Zero."
More than that, Myanmar's constitution provides that if a state of
emergency is declared, the commander-in-chief can be granted total
control of the country under circumstances including "disintegration of
national solidarity."
TESTING THE LIMITS OF PRESS FREEDOM
Slodkowski, the Reuters bureau chief, first met Wa Lone in 2016.
Wa Lone didn't speak English as well as another candidate Slodkowski was
interviewing: "I had trouble understanding everything he said." But Wa
Lone struck him as both curious and driven.
That was important to Slodkowski, who had been coming to Myanmar since
2009. Slodkowski's father was an underground journalist in Poland who
was arrested in 1982 and spent a year and a half in prison under an
authoritarian communist regime.
Wa Lone soon landed a job at Reuters. He'd been in Yangon for about six
years at that point, doing charity work, taking English classes and
working his way through a series of local newspapers.
He met the woman who became his wife, Pan Ei Mon, at one of them, the
Myanmar Times. The first time they went for coffee, in 2013, Wa Lone
asked Pan Ei Mon whether she had a boyfriend. She said that she did. "He
said, 'Okay, why don't you choose between him and me,'" she recalled,
smiling at the memory.
Before joining Reuters, he'd built a reputation for reporting about the
country's internal armed conflicts. At the Myanmar Times, where he
worked for about three years, Wa Lone was one of the first reporters to
reach an embattled border region in Shan State after a bout of fighting
in 2015 between the military and an armed ethnic militia.
Such violence has a long history in Myanmar. Civil warfare began almost
immediately after independence in 1948. Ethnic divisions that erupted in
fighting back then have endured. More than 20 armed groups pose a
central challenge for Aung San Suu Kyi and her government, who are
pursuing national peace talks. To the north of Shan State, for example,
among jade, amber and gold mines, it is the Kachin Independence Army
trading fire with government troops.
After arriving at Reuters, Wa Lone soon began reporting about Rakhine
State and the Rohingya Muslims. A story in October 2016 detailed
allegations that Myanmar soldiers raped eight Rohingya women at gunpoint
after coordinated Rohingya insurgent attacks on border posts. With Wa
Lone's name atop, the story quoted a Rohingya woman saying of a group of
soldiers: "Two men held me, one holding each arm, and another one held
me by my hair from the back and they raped me." Government spokesman Zaw
Htay denied the allegations when the story was published.
Wa Lone covered attacks by Rohingya Muslim militants as well. In August
of 2017, he reported on official accounts of coordinated assaults by the
militants on 30 police posts and an army base, killing 12 members of the
country's security forces. Those attacks would spark the military's
crackdown in Rakhine State.
The reporting traced a pattern in Rakhine in which insurgent strikes on
security forces were met with overwhelming force that drove increasing
numbers of Rohingya Muslims to flee the area.
Wa Lone pursued his job while facing difficulties making ends meet. His
wife, Pan Ei Mon, said Wa Lone made the equivalent of $1,000 a month at
Reuters, and she earned about $380 working in the advertising department
of a local newspaper. Wa Lone's annual income alone was about 10 times
the country's per capita gross national income. But living in the center
of Yangon, Pan Ei Mon said, "It was never enough."
They lived in a small apartment, a space subdivided from their
landlady's house. With Reuters headquarters often slow to reimburse
their expenses in the far-off Yangon bureau, reporters there said they
sometimes ran out of money after long trips before the next check. Both
Pan Ei Mon and Wa Lone pawned their wedding rings. They used an older
friend at the Myanmar Times to take the jewelry to avoid embarrassment,
said Pan Ei Mon. On one occasion, Wa Lone used the cash to help pay for
a reporting trip to Rakhine State.
[to top of second column]
|
Detained Reuters journalists Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo leave in a
police vehicle after a court hearing in Yangon, Myanmar May 29,
2018. REUTERS/Ann Wang/File Photo
Asked about its slowness to pay expenses in Yangon, Reuters said its
global system for reimbursing reporters depends on using a credit
card that isn't widely accepted in Myanmar. In recent months, the
news agency said in a written statement, it has made it possible for
staff there to be reimbursed more frequently. On the pawning of the
wedding rings, Reuters said: "We were not aware of this personal
sacrifice and it is not something we would ever ask or expect of
staff."
In investigating the massacre, Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo were on
dangerous ground, said Myat Swe, co-founder of the Myanmar Times. He
was arrested in 2004 by the military junta after his father, an
intelligence officer, was purged. He spent about nine years behind
bars for allegedly violating censorship laws. "What they did was
they threw me in the prison first and then they looked for the
case," said Myat Swe, now chief executive at Frontier Myanmar
magazine.
The military, he said, retains vast power, which Aung San Suu Kyi is
unable to check. "You can clearly see that she doesn't have any
influence whatsoever on the military," said Myat Swe, sitting in a
second-floor office where production notes for his magazine were
scribbled on glass walls.
That made Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo's reporting "quite risky," he
said, especially in Rakhine State, where the government is aware of
reporters' movements and locals don't like journalists, domestic or
foreign.
Under the junta, which lasted half a century, Myanmar had what was
regarded as one of the world's strictest systems of censorship.
After the junta installed a quasi-civilian government, the country
announced in 2012 that it was ending pre-publication censorship of
news reports. Later that year, it said that private daily
newspapers, shut down since 1964, could be published.
A fitful loosening and tightening followed – 10 journalists and
media executives were imprisoned in 2014, for example. As Aung San
Suu Kyi's party took power in 2016, expectations rose that she would
introduce an era of greater press freedom.
But journalists continue to be incarcerated. In June last year, the
military arrested three Myanmar reporters in Shan State for covering
a drug-burning event by an ethnic militia. They were charged under
the Unlawful Associations Act, a colonial-era law that broadly
prohibits contact with banned groups. The charges were dropped in
September.
Former Reuters journalist Aung Hla Tun knows what it is like to
cover the military. Ushering visitors into his office in Naypyitaw,
he pointed to an internal Reuters reporting award on a shelf which
he won for covering the Saffron Revolution protests in 2007. "I got
a chance to do my bit for democracy, for freedom of press for
Myanmar," he said.
That year, he produced a series of reports from the streets as
protesters defied the junta. In an internal Reuters note circulated
in October of 2007, Aung Hla Tun was praised for displaying
"enormous courage, resourcefulness and journalistic integrity in
putting us consistently ahead on the major breaks and turns in the
story."
He is no longer a reporter. Aung Hla Tun left Reuters at the end of
2016 and was named Myanmar's deputy information minister in January
2018. He said he chose to serve in the government out of loyalty to
Aung San Suu Kyi.
Sitting on a sofa, dressed like a typical Myanmar official in a
traditional sarong-like garment called a longyi, with neatly combed
hair, glasses and placid expression, he recounted the stories of his
own family members arrested by the former military regime.
He also talked about Wa Lone.
Aung Hla Tun worked with Wa Lone briefly in the Reuters bureau and
knew him before that as a member of the reporting community in
Yangon. While at the Myanmar Times, Wa Lone said he attended
sessions that Aung Hla Tun hosted for journalists looking to brush
up their English and improve their time management.
They considered each other friends. Aung Hla Tun attended Wa Lone's
wedding in 2016. A snapshot from the day shows him on stage, a place
of honor, with the beaming couple.
But Wa Lone said he and Aung Hla Tun disagreed over coverage of
events in Rakhine State. At one point, Aung Hla Tun said, he gave Wa
Lone advice: "be careful."
The prior Reuters bureau chief in Yangon, Paul Mooney, said Aung Hla
Tun referred to Rohingya Muslims as "Bengalis," a term implying they
are foreigners that's commonly used in Myanmar. When Buddhists
attacked Muslims during riots in the city of Mandalay in 2014,
Mooney said, Aung Hla Tun only wanted to relay official comment from
the capital. "If there was anything negative that might kind of make
the Burmese army look bad, he didn't want to be involved with it,"
Mooney said.
Aung Hla Tun disputed Mooney's descriptions of him. Mooney, he said,
tried to paint him as "anti-Muslim." However, he said, "I have many
Muslim friends."
Aung Hla Tun said he had asked officials in the government about Wa
Lone's case. But, Aung Hla Tun said, he discovered that it was
inadvisable to lobby for Wa Lone's release: "Some close friends
warned me, 'You should stop or you will be in danger.'" He did not
explain further.
"I have done my best, he was my friend," he said.
His voice strained as he spoke about the news agency's coverage of
Rakhine State. "Reuters should have apologized to the government.
Apologize!"
A MASS GRAVE IS DISCOVERED
In late October, Wa Lone flew to Sittwe, the capital of Rakhine. He
was with a colleague, reporter Simon Lewis; the two met up with Kyaw
Soe Oo after landing.
Where Wa Lone's face is full and his eyes animated above a mustache,
Kyaw Soe Oo has high cheekbones, his shoulders square on a leaner
frame. As a kid in Sittwe, he helped out local shops arranging and
dusting books, and in return was allowed to read them. As an adult,
he stacked bookshelves from floor to ceiling in his home. He read
the translated works of names like Kafka, Camus, Sartre.
His family owned boats and buses used to transport goods. When Kyaw
Soe Oo told them he was going to marry a woman who worked as a
household employee for his grandmother, they disapproved. He married
her anyway.
His wife, Chit Su Win, complained about all the books he was buying,
and Kyaw Soe Oo agreed not to add any more. "But then I bought more
and lied to her, saying that I got those from my friends," he said.
In 2012, riots exploded between Muslims and Buddhists in Rakhine
State. Growing up in Sittwe, the state capital, Kyaw Soe Oo was a
Buddhist living among Muslims his whole life. A family helper who
prepared his school lunches was Muslim. In the aftermath of the 2012
unrest, he'd watched in dismay as Rakhine Buddhists "bullied"
Muslims.
Kyaw Soe Oo said he felt compelled to report about the issue. "To be
frank, I would rather be a property agent than a reporter," he said.
"But if we don't solve this problem during my time, my daughter will
suffer the consequences."
After his arrest, his wife, Chit Su Win, moved to Yangon from
Rakhine State. She says she's now concerned it is unsafe to return.
Many in the Buddhist majority back home in Sittwe were furious that
Kyaw Soe Oo had helped a reporting effort about crimes against
Muslims. He and Wa Lone have received a torrent of death threats on
social media since their arrest.
"Because of the story, people in Rakhine really do not like my
husband now," she said of the massacre article.
While Lewis conducted interviews in Sittwe last October, Wa Lone and
Kyaw Soe Oo took a ferry and got motorbike taxis to head further
into the state's interior. On the way, Kyaw Soe Oo's driver
mentioned that 10 Muslim men had been killed in the area. He and Wa
Lone switched rides so that Wa Lone could hear the details. As they
cut past rice paddies, the wind whipping in their faces, the driver
leaned back and shouted answers. There'd been 10 men killed by
soldiers and a group of villagers with swords, he said.
The news was related in a matter-of-fact way. "He doesn't like
Muslims," Wa Lone later explained. "I don't think he thought this is
a big crime – an issue of morality or something."
They arrived at the village, called Inn Din, and others there
repeated the story.
Lewis remembers Wa Lone calling him and saying: "These guys are
telling us there is a grave and they are offering to show us. I'm
not sure if we should do that." Lewis added: "He was scared."
The grave was hard to find. The reporters walked through bushes and
noticed newly cut branches marking a path on the side of a hill.
There were barely buried bones on the ground, said Wa Lone. There
were other bones scattered nearby. Wa Lone thought to himself that a
dog may have been gnawing on them.
During his trip, a villager gave Wa Lone a photograph of 10 Rohingya
men kneeling with more than a dozen men behind them, many holding
assault rifles. The 10 had been detained by security forces.
After returning to Yangon, Wa Lone obtained another picture. This
one showed the bodies of the 10 Rohingya men in a shallow grave. It
was the same men, in the same t-shirts, but now some were face down
in the dirt, limbs splayed, others with mouths agape toward the
heavens, and blood everywhere.
In the photograph of the men kneeling, there's a man at the back
left corner of the frame with a ball cap on backwards and holding a
gun with what looked like the number eight written in Burmese on the
stock. It was a clue: At least some of the men in the image belonged
to Myanmar's police battalion 8 – the same battalion as that of
Lance Corporal Naing Lin, the man Wa Lone would later meet on the
evening of Dec. 12.
Wa Lone, said Slodkowski, grew "obsessed" with identifying the
policemen in the photograph. At the time, the United Nations was
alleging widespread abuses by the military in Rakhine State; the
government responded by saying it would look into any evidence
presented to it.
"Let's give them evidence then," Slodkowski recalls Wa Lone saying.
Wa Lone devised ways to meet Battalion 8 police members so he could
ask for phone numbers of other officers. He plugged those numbers
into the search bar of Facebook, which is wildly popular in Myanmar,
said Slodkowski. He looked for faces that matched those in the
background of the photograph of the 10 Rohingya men.
Wa Lone also printed an enlargement of at least one face from among
the armed men standing behind the kneeling Rohingya, said
Slodkowski. Wa Lone took the image to other officers of Battalion 8
and asked whether they recognized their comrade.
His pursuit of the members of Battalion 8 would ultimately land him
in jail, according to testimony in his trial.
A Battalion 8 captain named Moe Yan Naing testified that the police
planned to "entrap" Wa Lone. He said he was present when a police
brigadier general told Naing Lin to call Wa Lone, arrange the
meeting and plant documents on the reporter before arresting him.
The brigadier general, he testified, issued a blunt threat to the
cops: "If you don't get Wa Lone, you will go to jail."
After saying so in court, Moe Yan Naing was sentenced to a year in
prison for violating police discipline, a development that police
said was unrelated to his testimony.
The prosecution also presented police witnesses who backed the
official version of events: They said the two reporters were
detained, already in possession of the documents, during a random
search at a police checkpoint.
'SHUT YOUR MOUTH'
On the night of their arrests, Kyaw Soe Oo said, he didn't realize
the men in plainclothes who surrounded Wa Lone were police. He was
going to help Wa Lone but then was grabbed from behind. "I thought
they were pickpockets," Kyaw Soe Oo later testified.
At the police station, Wa Lone testified, the two reporters were
confronted by more than a dozen men in uniform and plainclothes. One
asked Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo if they were spies. When Wa Lone said
he didn't know what was in the documents Naing Lin had handed him, a
cop replied: "Shut your mouth."
Next, both reporters later testified, they were taken to a building
not far from downtown Yangon. It was the Aung Tha Pyay interrogation
center, a nondescript building where special branch police officers
do their work.
Wa Lone said the police pulled a fabric sack over his head on the
way there. He was then picked up by his armpits and carried up a set
of stairs. When the sack was pulled off, there were officers sitting
behind a table in front of him.
The interrogators, Wa Lone told the court, already had a list of the
policemen he'd spoken to. They demanded he answer the same
questions, over and over, in two-hour sessions, for almost three
days straight: What did the policemen of Battalion 8 tell him? What
was he reporting on?
In those sleepless days of interrogation, Wa Lone told the court,
the police pressured him to share his cell phone password. He
resisted. The phone, he knew, contained something that would grab
the attention of the police: the photographs of the 10 Muslim men.
But he was tired "from hours of continuous interrogations," he
testified. And he was scared things could get worse if he didn't
relent. So he gave up the code. Before that moment, Wa Lone said,
"We did not talk about the killings in Inn Din."
One officer, he told the court, offered "possible negotiations" if
Reuters would agree not to publish the story. Wa Lone said he
rejected the overture.
His interrogators also berated him for having looked into the
killings.
"They said, 'You are both Buddhists. Why are you writing about
'kalars' at a time like this?'" Wa Lone testified, quoting a
derogatory Burmese term many use to describe people of South Asian
descent, especially Muslims.
Kyaw Soe Oo described coming under similar pressure. At one point,
he testified, an interrogator burst into his cell to ask about the
photographs of the 10 doomed men from Inn Din: "Why haven't you told
us about this?" the interrogator said. Kyaw Soe Oo said he was then
made to kneel on the floor for at least three hours as punishment.
Another time, Kyaw Soe Oo testified, a military intelligence officer
brought print-outs of the photos and asked whether he had "sent the
photos from my phone to human rights organizations from foreign
countries."
Captain Myint Lwin, the officer in charge of the Yangon police
station that conducted the preliminary inquiry after the reporters'
arrests, denied in court that Kyaw Soe Oo was made to kneel during
his questioning. He also said that neither reporter was transferred
to Aung Tha Pyay interrogation center. Calls to a police spokesman
seeking comment about the reporters' testimony went unanswered.
When Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo were arrested, their story about the
massacre had yet to be completed. Their colleagues Lewis and
Slodkowski finished the piece over the following two months. Wa
Lone's wife, Pan Ei Mon, whose pregnancy was advancing while her
husband sat in prison, said in an interview that she was against
running it. Pan Ei Mon had been speaking with a Myanmar government
official who told her he was concerned Wa Lone "would be made an
example of."
The story established that soldiers were among those who killed the
Rohingya in Inn Din village, and Pan Ei Mon thought that publishing
would shut off any sympathetic channels in the government.
Wa Lone took a different view. He told a Reuters lawyer he wanted
the story to run. It appeared in early February.
"After that story was released, I decided not to visit Wa Lone
anymore," Pan Ei Mon said. "I thought all he cared about was his ego
– not me or the baby inside me." The next day, she relented and went
to see him.
Wa Lone received other visitors after the story ran. Several senior
police officers met him in a room at the prison and videotaped the
interview, he testified at his trial. Among the officers, he said,
was the brigadier general who, according to earlier court testimony
by Capt. Moe Yan Naing, gave the order to set up and arrest the
Reuters reporters. The brigadier general asked Wa Lone to reveal the
sources for the Inn Din story. Wa Lone said he refused to give up
any names.
He and Kyaw Soe Oo have been in jail for 240 days. On April 11 they
had yet another court appearance. It was Wa Lone's 32nd birthday.
The day before, the military announced that seven soldiers were
sentenced to 10 years in prison with hard labor for participating in
the Inn Din massacre. With that, Myanmar's generals appeared to be
acknowledging the truth of Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo's reporting about
the killings in Inn Din.
The tailgate of a police truck opened to let out the police officers
guarding Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo. Pan Ei Mon was waiting, brushing
her hair back from her face with a wide smile. She was about five
months pregnant.
In the passageway where she stood, there was a birthday cake on a
chair. The group of more than half a dozen policemen let Wa Lone
pause to blow out the candles. He walked into the courtroom
grinning.
Inside, the judge declined a motion by the defense to dismiss the
case against the reporters. Wa Lone's wife wept. Kyaw Soe Oo's wife
wept.
On his way out of the courtroom, Wa Lone paused and shouted at the
cameras pointing at him. "The culprits who committed the massacre
were sentenced to 10 years in prison. However, the ones who reported
on it – us – are accused under a law that can get us imprisoned for
14 years," he said. "So, I'd like to ask the government: Where is
the truth? Where is the truth and justice? Where is democracy and
freedom?"
The police then led him and Kyaw Soe Oo into the back of the truck.
Its tailgate clanged shut. And they were gone.
(Additional reporting by Shoon Naing, Sam Aung Moon and Thu Thu Aung
in Yangon. Edited by Peter Hirschberg.)
[© 2018 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.]
Copyright 2018 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content. |