Judge signals skepticism in Trump team's
bid to block Obamacare suit
Send a link to a friend
[December 20, 2018]
By Sarah N. Lynch
BALTIMORE (Reuters) - A U.S. judge signaled
skepticism on Wednesday toward a bid by President Donald Trump's
administration to block a lawsuit by the state of Maryland seeking to
preserve the Obamacare law in a case that also challenges Trump's
appointment of Matthew Whitaker as acting attorney general.
At a hearing before U.S. District Judge Ellen Hollander in Baltimore,
Justice Department attorney Hashim Mooppan declined to disclose whether
Whitaker is involved in deciding the future of the 2010 healthcare law,
formally called the Affordable Care Act, after a judge in Texas last
week found it unconstitutional.
Whitaker, a Trump political loyalist named after the Republican
president ousted Jeff Sessions as attorney general last month, is facing
a series of legal challenges to the legality of his appointment.
The lawsuit by Democratic Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh asks
Hollander to declare Obamacare constitutional and to find that Whitaker
was unlawfully appointed. Trump's administration has worked to undermine
Obamacare after Congress failed in a Republican effort to repeal the
law.
The administration asked Hollander to throw out Maryland's case and
argued the state lacked legal standing to sue because it cannot prove it
has been harmed merely by a decision by Sessions while he was attorney
general not to defend Obamacare in the Texas case.
On Friday, U.S. District Judge Reed O'Connor in Fort Worth ruled that
the Affordable Care Act, championed by Trump's Democratic predecessor
Barack Obama, was unconstitutional following revisions to the tax code
made last year by Congress, which removed a penalty for failing to
obtain health insurance. The law was challenged by a group of states
including Texas.
Mooppan told Hollander if Maryland wanted to defend the
constitutionality of Obamacare, it could have joined other states that
intervened in the Texas case to protect the law. Mooppan said Maryland
also had not sustained any injury because the U.S. Health and Human
Services Department pledged to continue enforcing Obamacare pending the
conclusion of the litigation despite O'Connor's ruling in Texas.
"What injures Maryland is what happens in the real world. What we write
in legal briefs cannot injure Maryland," Mooppan said.
[to top of second column]
|
A sign on an insurance store advertises Obamacare in San Ysidro, San
Diego, California, U.S., October 26, 2017. REUTERS/Mike Blake/File
Photo
Hollander appeared skeptical, noting that Trump's prior Twitter
posts supporting the dismantling of Obamacare, coupled with
O'Connor's order, injected uncertainty about the health insurance
marketplace's future and could lead one to reasonably believe the
law may not be enforced.
"Doesn't Maryland have to take steps now to protect itself?" the
judge asked. "Can it do nothing to protect itself while all of this
is playing out? What are you supposed to do? Sit back?"
Tom Goldstein, one of two attorneys arguing for Maryland, said the
state was injured by the fact that an official illegitimately
appointed is presumably presiding over Obamacare's future.
Maryland sought an injunction barring Whitaker from serving as
acting attorney general, saying his appointment violated the
Constitution and a federal law governing the Justice Department's
line of succession.
If Hollander finds Obamacare constitutional, that would create a
conflict with the Texas ruling and could lead the U.S. Supreme Court
to weigh in. The high court previously has upheld Obamacare.
Hollander asked fewer questions regarding Whitaker's appointment and
indicated the issue could become moot. Trump on Dec. 7 said he would
nominate William Barr to become attorney general on a permanent
basis. He would replace Whitaker, pending a Senate confirmation
process likely in early 2019.
The number of Americans who signed up for 2019 Obamacare insurance
plans fell by about 4 percent compared to the prior year, government
data released on Wednesday showed.
(Reporting by Sarah N. Lynch; Editing by Will Dunham)
[© 2018 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.]
Copyright 2018 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.
|