Battle-scarred creditors call for reforms from LatAm
default duo
Send a link to a friend
[August 24, 2020] By
Tom Arnold and Rodrigo Campos
LONDON/NEW YORK (Reuters) - As serial
defaulters Argentina and Ecuador near the finishing line on their latest
sovereign debt overhauls, foreign creditors are nervy about investing
again without macroeconomic reforms and International Monetary Fund
support.
On the surface, the prospects for both countries look brighter. Absent
complicated negotiations with the IMF, a clean slate post-debt
restructuring will allow them to focus on reviving their
COVID-19-ravaged economies with much less concern about looming foreign
debts to repay.
But both governments will be painfully aware they need to woo back
investor support to ensure their path to recovery - not an easy
challenge given their tarnished track-records that combine for about 20
defaults.
Argentina's government hopes to wrap up its latest $65 billion debt
restructuring by end-August. Ecuador, having gained support for its plan
relatively quickly, is also finalising its $17.4 billion foreign debt
revamp.
"In of itself, these deals are a positive first step but there is a lot
more work to be done to firm up the outlook for investment," said Graham
Stock, an emerging markets strategist at BlueBay Asset Management, and a
creditor to both countries.
"There's plenty of goodwill (from creditors) but there's a question of
(government) actions rather than just good intentions."
Most immediately focus will turn to engagement with the IMF.
Ecuador's deal was predicated on a fresh agreement with the IMF, giving
many investors faith in the commitment of President Lenin Moreno's
administration to revamp the stalled $4.2 billion IMF lending programme.
For a graphic on Current schedule of payments to the IMF:
https://graphics.reuters.com/
ARGENTINA-ECUADOR/
INVESTMENT/oakpeoqowpr/chart.png
Argentina's talks may be trickier. Economy Minister Martin Guzman has
warned of "tough" negotiations that may not lead to a deal on a new
program until early 2021.
"It's going to be a very difficult discussion," said Mauro Roca,
emerging markets sovereign research managing director at TCW.
"The IMF will ask for some policy conditionality and Argentina at this
point doesn't seem willing to accept important changes in the direction
of policy. That would be seen as interventionist, so that discussion is
going to be difficult and it’s going to take a while."
Ecuador's sovereign bonds have generally outperformed Argentina's since
May, which analysts said partly reflected Quito's friendlier talks with
creditors.
For a graphic on Ecuador vs Argentina USD bond prices:
https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/
gfx/mkt/yxmpjnoyepr/Capture.PNG
[to top of second column] |
POLITICAL WILL
Hopes of generating economic revival while ensuring debt sustainability -
expected to stabilise at about 100% of GDP in Argentina's case - hinges on
politics.
"It's going to depend on the macroeconomic conditions and the policy regime,
particularly the direction of economic policy," TCW's Roca said. "If those
policies are not considered to be sustainable nobody would put money to work,
particularly in FDI or something that requires looking down the road."
A "glass half-full" scenario could see Argentina at the start of a virtuous
circle, propelled by the "right policy mix" initiated by a Alberto Fernandez
administration that had more political capital than his predecessor Mauricio
Macri could have dreamed of, said Patrick Esteruelas, head of research at EMSO
Asset Management.
"The problem is that glass half full is full of holes," he said. "The historical
fiscal multiplier in Argentina is very low which means any debt service relief
does not translate into real activity gains. You need to see wholesale changes
to a medium-term economic program that I don't think this government, despite
its political capital, is willing to endorse."
Goldman Sachs said it was sceptical about prospects for comprehensive tax
reform.
In Ecuador's case, investors are wary after unsuccessful attempts last year by
Moreno to push through tax and monetary reforms intended to cut a burdensome
fiscal deficit with elections coming up in 2021.
"With elections round the corner, and with the COVID-19 impact, the space and
willingness to undertake difficult measures could be lower," said Raza Agha,
head of emerging markets credit strategy at Legal & General Investment
Management.
Currency woes raise another red flag as locals have piled savings into the U.S.
dollar in recent years.
Argentina could see more foreign exchange controls amid still latent dollar
demand, said Siobhan Morden, head of Latin America fixed income strategy at
Amherst Pierpont Securities.
Lack of domestic confidence in Argentina's peso was a "massive problem" that
needed fixing before investment would flow properly, said Carl Ross of GMO.
The currencies of both nations were overvalued, the Institute of International
Finance (IIF) said this month, and real depreciation was needed to prevent
unsustainable current account deficits.
It might be hard for Argentina to correct overvaluation unless the government
allowed it to float more freely, the IIF said.
"Ecuador faces the tallest challenge, as dollarization makes relative price
adjustments unavoidable," it added.
(Additional reporting by Marc Jones in London; Editing by Chizu Nomiyama)
[© 2020 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.] Copyright 2020 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content. |