|
 Lt. Gov. Julianna Stratton, the second-ranking member of Gov.
J.B. Pritzker’s administration, said Sept. 24that to adequately address the
state’s budget crisis, “lawmakers will be forced to consider raising income
taxes on all Illinois residents by at least 20%, regardless of their level of
income.”
The warning came during an online “fair tax virtual rally” hosted by the Vote
Yes For Fairness Committee, the political organization backing the progressive
income tax amendment which Pritzker has funded to the tune of $56.5 million.
Stratton apparently intended for the comment to pressure voters into passing the
progressive tax on the Nov. 3 ballot. Then on Sept. 25 Pritzker expanded on the
threat, saying there either would be a 20% income tax hike or a 15% cut in state
spending, “which would significantly reduce education funding at the state
level.”
But Illinois has better options than massive tax hikes or holding schoolchildren
hostage. Structural spending reforms to public pensions and to other drivers of
overspending would actually fix state finances, rather than Pritzker trying to
tax his way out of a spending hole that keeps getting bigger. Pritzker has
ignored or blocked those reforms and relied on the same false choice narrative
since his first-year budget address.
More money won’t fix things: S&P Global Ratings on Sept. 21 made it clear that
Illinois faces a 5% budget gap even if the progressive tax were to pass. That is
despite a 1.8% growth in tax revenue between fiscal year 2019 and 2020, ranking
Illinois No. 5 in the nation and beating the average of a 5.5% decline.
The Chicago Tribune’s editorial board hit Pritzker and Stratton for the threats
and doubted they could muster enough state lawmaker votes for a tax hike.
“But the threat alone suggests that voters are pushing back against his proposed
constitutional amendment, understanding it for what it is: Not just a tax
increase on the super-rich but a scheme of graduated rates that politicians
likely will exploit – just as soon as they can – to soak middle-class taxpayers,
too.”
The progressive tax, also called the “fair tax” by its supporters, would
eliminate the 1970 Illinois Constitution’s flat tax protection that ensures no
one’s taxes are hiked unless everyone’s taxes are hiked. The protection is
intended to make state lawmakers cautious because raising taxes creates voter
backlash.
The change would grant permanent new taxing authority to Illinois politicians,
making it easier for them to raise taxes on everyone, one group at a time –
including opening the door to a retirement tax. Research from the non-partisan
Illinois Policy Institute has found the progressive tax would hike taxes on more
than 100,000 small businesses and kill at least 56,000 jobs under the initial
rates passed by the Illinois General Assembly.
But as the Tribune stated, no one expects state lawmakers to stop at the initial
rates. The last state to pass a progressive tax, Connecticut in 1996, hiked
taxes on the middle class 13% despite initial promises lawmakers only wanted to
tax the rich.
Stratton admitted the harms of hiking taxes in an already high-tax state,
saying, “We all know that our middle- and lower-income families cannot withstand
a 20% tax increase and it will only serve to deepen the dramatic inequities that
we already see across the state. It will drive out our residents and it will
drive out investment in Illinois.” While this is true, the lieutenant governor
seemed to be saying the administration’s revenue demands would be more important
than these harms.
[
to
top of second column] |
This admission is a break with past rhetoric from
the administration, which has sought to sell its progressive income
tax hike plan as a way to lower taxes for the working poor and
middle class. However, these claims were always lacking important
context and often based on inaccurate information.
The amendment does nothing to lower Illinois’
second-highest in the nation property taxes. It would leave the
poorest Illinoisans paying the third-highest overall tax burden in
the nation, $1,800, while gaining barely enough of a break for a
fast food meal.
Working-class families were already disproportionately harmed by
doubled gas taxes and hiked vehicle registration fees when Pritzker
signed off on 20 new or higher taxes and fees in his first year. A
typical suburban family could end up paying $1,700 more in
vehicle-related taxes after those hikes.
The Pritzker’s administration’s budget crisis is largely of its own
making.
The governor in June signed a budget that increased spending by $2.4
billion over last year despite significantly lower expected revenues
resulting from the pandemic. He refused to even discuss canceling or
postponing pay raises for state workers that cost taxpayers $261
million. That budget has a $6 billion deficit. It relies on $5
billion from a non-existent federal bailout or additional borrowing,
as well as more than $1 billion from the progressive tax hike voters
have not approved.
Pritzker previously warned of 5% cuts to state government during the
current budget year if he does not receive a federal bailout,
calling those cuts a “nightmare scenario.” He did not offer a new
superlative for his new threat of a 15% cut if he doesn’t get his
“fair tax.”
Progressive tax powers would give state leaders a “divide and
conquer” ability without the threat of voters punishing them at the
next election. Lawmakers fear that ability: about 30% were forced to
retire or were voted out of office after the 2017 tax hike passed.
Progressive tax states make it easier for politicians to target the
middle class to raise revenue. In fact, 18 of 32 states with a
progressive income tax hit the middle class with the same maximum
tax rate paid by millionaires.
Every state with a progressive tax also taxes retirement income.
Rather than threatening further tax hikes or essential service cuts
if they don’t get their way, Illinois lawmakers should look to
reforms that fix spending, not that fix taxing.
A recent report from the Illinois Policy Institute, “Illinois
Forward,” details the history of the state’s self-made financial
crisis as well as commonsense reforms to fully fund public pensions,
balance budgets, reduce debt and lower everyone’s taxes over time.
Pritzker and other “fair tax” backers should stop standing in the
way of needed reforms and stop trying to scare taxpayers into
granting them permanent new taxing power.
Click here to respond to the editor about this article
|
