Analysis - A tale of two tapers: This time is different for a Fed
focused on jobs
Send a link to a friend
[April 12, 2021] By
Howard Schneider and Ann Saphir
WASHINGTON/SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Eight
years ago this month Jerome Powell, still in his rookie year as a
Federal Reserve governor, surveyed the U.S. job market and declared it
was good enough for the central bank to reduce the support for the
economy it had rolled out to fight the 2007 to 2009 financial crisis.
The unemployment rate had just hit a post-crisis low of roughly 7.5%.
But for Blacks it remained a catastrophic 13%, a fact not raised by
Powell or any other policymaker during their meeting.
"We've achieved substantial progress towards our economic objectives,"
Powell told his colleagues according to transcripts of that April 30-May
1, 2013, Federal Open Market Committee meeting. He encouraged them to
reduce the Fed's monthly bond buying at "the next plausible
opportunity."
The "taper" from that earlier crisis began later in 2013.

The Fed is again confronting a similar debate with Powell now its chair
- singing a markedly different tune. The shift in his language on the
matter now shows how fully the central bank has switched gears to
emphasize maximum employment as the paramount of its two congressionally
mandated goals.
Though markers like unemployment insurance claims and labor force
participation are, because of the pandemic, worse today than they were
when the Fed started withdrawing crisis support the last time, some
broad indexes of labor market health are in fact better now than they
were then.
GRAPHIC: Tapering, now and then - https://graphics.reuters.com/USA-FED/TAPER/jznvnaemqpl/chart.png
Yet Powell, who speaks of the homeless people he sees on his commute as
a measure of his job performance, says he is nowhere near ready to pull
back on the throttle. In fact he cringes at labor market data like the
current Black unemployment rate of 9.6%, which is far better than when
he was ready to tighten policy after the last crisis.
The Fed today "has a different view of what constitutes full
employment," said Nick Bunker, economic research director for the Indeed
Hiring Lab. "The labor market may be roughly as healthy as it was at the
end of 2013, but the Fed thinks it's further from full employment."
TAKING THE OPPOSITE BET
The Fed's commitment to this new approach will be tested in coming
months with an expected jump in inflation, beginning this week when data
due on Tuesday is likely to show consumer prices in March rose 2.5% from
a year earlier.
Though largely due to comparison with weak prices at the start of the
pandemic last spring, the surge in the index will likely mark the
beginning of what Fed officials acknowledge will be a "tricky" battle to
convince the public, financial markets and elected officials that higher
inflation is what the economy needs, with wage gains and higher headline
growth likely to come with it.
It's a hard argument to win if gas prices skyrocket this summer and the
airline travel people avoided during the pandemic becomes too expensive.
"Price stability," defined by the Fed as inflation averaging 2%
annually, is its second area of responsibility. Fed policymakers have
spent much of the last decade trying to understand why inflation
remained below the targeted level despite efforts to lift it.
Their conclusion is inflation is generically weak, so much so they can
take some calculated risks around it.
Previously Fed officials saw inflation and unemployment levels as
closely linked: Low joblessness drove prices higher, and a falling
unemployment rate offered a cue for when to make economic conditions
more restrictive so prices would not rise too fast.
[to top of second column] |

Traders work, as a
screen shows Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell's news
conference on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New
York, U.S., October 30, 2019. REUTERS/Brendan McDermid/File Photo

That's what they were doing in 2013. Even though the unemployment rate
was high, around 7%, when the Fed announced its bond taper, it was
expected to drop quickly. Officials did not want to fall behind in
tailoring policy to fit the improving economy.
GRAPHIC: "Substantial" progress? -
https://graphics.reuters.com/USA-FED/INFLATION/
bdwvkbrwdpm/chart.png
Now, they are prepared to take the opposite gamble: that they can wait
for unemployment to fall ever lower without much danger of inflation
becoming unmoored.
Many are skeptical. A coming jump in short-lived "base effects"
inflation may ease quickly. On the horizon, though, are the impact of
pandemic-driven supply bottlenecks like the current microchip shortage,
a potential surge in demand for in-person services as those become safe
again, and a government spending pipeline turbocharged with coronavirus
aid and potentially new infrastructure spending.
"There is a massive experiment under way," said Edward Al-Hussainy,
senior rates analyst with Columbia Threadneedle. "We are going to try to
run the economy hot. We have a bunch of supply-side constraints left
over from COVID. The economy is reconfiguring after the COVID shock, and
we don't know how that is going to result in how prices are formed."

ADDRESSING AN UNEQUAL BURDEN
Markets are betting the Fed will have to raise interest rates sooner
than telegraphed, and if there is a severe enough inflation surprise "a
hard landing cannot be ruled out," said Karen Dynan, a Harvard
University economics professor and senior fellow at the Peterson
Institute for International Economics.
But after arguably jumping the gun in ending crisis programs last time,
the Fed is now ready to err in the other direction, with the hope that
women find their way back to the labor force a bit faster, people of
color regain the economic footing they had before the health crisis, or
perhaps that the tent city along Powell's route home disappears.
The current unemployment rate is 6% now and by the Fed's projections is
heading to 4.5% by year's end, a level that previously would have been
seen as a trigger for faster inflation.
Jobs openings are surging and the million-a-month job additions expected
perhaps through this summer dwarf the strongest employment showings of
the last recovery.
For the Powell of 2021, it isn't enough.
"The economic downturn has not fallen equally on all Americans, and
those least able to shoulder the burden have been the hardest hit,"
Powell said in March after a Fed meeting that reaffirmed its pledge to
keep pouring help into the economy. "We understand that our actions
affect communities, families and businesses across the country."
(Reporting by Howard Schneider; Editing by Dan Burns and Andrea Ricci)
[© 2021 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.] Copyright 2021 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content. |