‘Almost impossible to prove’ defamation cases brought against elected
officials
Send a link to a friend
[November 12, 2021]
By Greg Bishop
(The Center Square) – The attorney suing
the governor for defamation may have a high burden to prove his case.
After being called a “grifter” by Gov. J.B. Pritzker, Attorney Thomas
DeVore filed a defamation case in Sangamon County late last month.
Pritzker’s comments came after DeVore filed a lawsuit against COVID-19
mandates in schools on behalf of more than 700 parents.
“So to make the suggestion that somehow or another these people were
stolen from for all intents and purposes is completely out of bounds,”
DeVore told.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2021/Nov/12/images/ads/current/countryfinancial_lda_PPP_2018.png)
He said he’s not a thief, didn’t dupe anyone and the governor’s comments
have a chilling effect, keeping people from speaking up or taking action
against policies they disagree with.
DeVore is seeking damages of more than $50,000.
While some suggest the governor has executive immunity, DeVore
downplayed that idea.
“Ultimately, the governor can’t just say whatever he wants to say about
somebody in that fashion, he doesn’t have that ability,” DeVore said.
[to top of second column]
|
![](../images/111221PIX/news_a43.jpg)
Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker gives a speech in Springfield on Monday,
Jan. 14, 2019.
BlueRoomStream
![](../images/ads/current/centraldirect_lda_SPONSOR_2021.png)
Loyola School of Law professor Allen Shoenberger said
case law on defamation claims against elected officials like
governors requires a high level of proof
“Unless he knows it’s not true, he can say it,” Shoenberger said.
The plaintiff must prove the defendant knew the statement wasn’t
true or was made with reckless disregard whether it was true or not,
Shoenberger said.
“Those requirements are almost impossible to prove in the real
world,” Shoenberger said. “Unless you have an audio recording of the
governor saying something like ‘I know it’s untrue, but I’m going to
say it anyway.’”
A hearing in DeVore’s Sangamon County case against the governor has
not been set. Shoenberger said such a case could be dismissed at the
pleading phase of a case.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2021/Nov/12/images/ads/current/Peasley_lda_PPP_2018.png) |