Op-Ed: Weisenstein: Good luck finding
price tag on Amendment 1
By Brad Weisenstein
Pension spending has grown 533% since 2000 and forced 14% cuts to a
range of core services, including child protection, mental health,
public health and public safety
|
When was the last time an Illinois politician told
you how much something was going to cost before the fact?
No one said what it would cost when Mike Madigan and other drafters of the 1970
Illinois Constitution bowed to government-union pressure and put in a clause
guaranteeing public pensions could never be changed. Fifty-two years later, we
now know the cost: $313 billion, or about $64,000 per Illinois household.
State law says the cost should be known when new state laws are passed. In 2019
the Illinois General Assembly passed 1,179 bills. Just 62 carried a price tag.
Now union bosses and even some media claim there’s nothing about property taxes
in Amendment 1, the so-called “Workers’ Rights Amendment” at the top of the
ballot Nov. 8.
But what the heck ever happens when government unions gain power in Illinois?
Does government get any cheaper?
The Chicago Tribune got it when they joined four other news editorial boards in
recommending voters reject Amendment 1: “Moreover, since the public sector also
has to raise funds to cover its cost, the amendment seems likely to put pressure
on property taxes and other sources of government revenues. We’ve not heard a
viable counterargument to that. It certainly won’t reduce the size or expenses
of government.”
Amendment 1 elevates the rights and powers of Illinois’ government unions above
our own. It also restricts state lawmakers from ever changing those powers – the
same kind of guarantee that gave Illinois the nation’s biggest public pension
debt.
We don’t have massive pension debt because we fail to put enough money towards
it – it eats over 25% of the state budget. And pension spending has grown 533%
since 2000 and forced 14% cuts to a range of core services, including child
protection, mental health, public health and public safety – all things we
expect our taxes and state government to do on behalf of our most vulnerable
residents.
[to top of second column] |
If you think we are dealing with a group of hapless, underpaid government
workers, think again. Illinois has 132,188 government workers making $100,000 or
more for a grand total of $17 billion. They include prison barbers making
$104,000 and Chicago bus drivers making $242,812.
It would seem their negotiating powers already are more than adequate. The
average Illinoisan earns $54,586 and carries the nation’s heaviest state and
local tax burden to pay those government costs.
The Illinois Policy Institute projects property taxes will rise $4 billion by
2026 at the current rate of growth if nothing is done. Half of that will be on
residential property, at an average of $2,149 per household. Amendment 1 would
give government unions more power to boost their paychecks and block property
tax reforms.
That means those property taxes to support local government could rise much more
than the $4 billion. State taxes could rise faster, too, and Illinoisans are
already out an extra $5.24 billion from doubling the gas tax and all the other
little taxes Gov. J.B. Pritzker got passed in 2019.
Yup. There’s nothing about property taxes in the Amendment 1 ballot language.
Brad Weisenstein is managing editor for the Illinois Policy
Institute.
|