2023 Logan County Fair

Doug DeMay Chili Cook-off brings the heat to a cool damp day at the Logan County Fair

Send a link to a friend  Share

[August 11, 2023]   On Saturday, the Annual Doug DeMay Memorial Chili Cook-off was a great place for hungry fairgoers. Competitors from around the county gave everyone an opportunity to sample their chili.

The annual event is held at the Knights of Columbus Pavilion the final weekend of the Logan County Fair. After event founder Doug Demay died suddenly in 2017, the event was named after him. Doug Ritterbush has been in charge of the event since then but will hand over the reins to someone else next year.

Whether you like chili mild, hot, spicy, sweet, garlicky, meaty, with or without beans, you can find almost any type of chili to suit your tastes.

This year’s cook-off had ten competitors. Among the many cook-off veterans were a few new faces.

For several of the contestants, the cook off has become a tradition and the same can be about many who come to sample the chili. It is a tasty tradition.
In the cook-off, most contestants use a variety of meats, beans, seasonings and spices to give their chili its own special flavor.

The competitors included:



First timer Jaedyn Gulley, who said he uses sweeter vegetables to give his chili a special flavor.



Second year competitors Patrick Gettleman and Shawn Edwards, who said they brought their secret ingredients. They also said their wives are the spice that makes everything better.



Tommy Cecil, who has competed a couple times, said the chili is fun to make. After placing second last year, he hoped to make it to first place this year.



Kevin Ritchhart, who has also competed a couple times, said making chili is about the seasoning. He uses a special seasoning and adjusts the amount as needed. It is sometimes spicy.



Lisa Conrady, another second time competitor, said she likes making chili and likes it sweet.



First time competitor Nick White, who partnered with Nuthatch Hill BBQ. White said he uses Brooks and Nuthatch seasoning, ground brisket and Italian sausage to make his chili a little different.



Long time competitor Dave Eyrse used sirloin steak in his chili this year to change it up a bit.



Evan Aughenbaugh, Andy Krusz and Alek “Porky” Schonauer were participating in the chili cook-off for the first time. They said their chili was made with love and joked that they were shooting for being in the top ten [places].

[to top of second column]



Sandy and Jim Bobell are long time competitors who won the cook-off in both 2015 and 2022. They said the chili is just a regular chili, but possibly meatier than some.



Though not new to the chili-cookoff, Ryder and Brantley Conrady, who have helped their parents with the cooking in the past, were the main cooks this year. The Conrady boys did the stirring and mixing with some help from their father Brett. Ryder said the chili is good.

Among the many trying the chili was the new fair royalty, who tried a little bit of each one. Those who sample the chili seem to enjoy a variety of flavor combinations.



When everyone’s chili was done cooking, judges sampled each chili and carefully considered what scores to give them.

The top three winners receive plaques, and the top team will have their name on a plaque that is placed in the fair office. Cash prizes are also awarded to the top three.

Since Ritterbush was able to find some generous sponsors in addition to what is given by the fair, the cash prizes were bigger than they used to be.

The third place winner received $250, the second prize winner received $350 and the first place winner received $500. $125 was given to the team who had the best presentation and $363 dollars were given by those voting for the people’s choice award.

2023 chili cook-off winners included:



People’s Choice:
Ryder and Brantley Conrady.



Best Presentation:
Lisa Conrady



First Place:
Tommy Cecil



Second Place:
Jim and Sandy Bobell



Third Place:
Evan Aughenbaugh, Andy Krusz and Alek “Porky” Schonauer, who chose to donate half their winnings to the Knights of Columbus and the other half to “Flako” [for cancer research].

[Angela Reiners]

< Recent features

Back to top