Investors see long wait for enlarged BRICS' economic boon
Send a link to a friend
[August 26, 2023] By
Rachel Savage and Karin Strohecker
JOHANNESBURG/LONDON (Reuters) - The expansion of the BRICS group of
developing countries could provide a lifeline to capital-starved new
entrants Iran and Argentina, but investors and analysts say a broader
economic boon for the bloc's members is far from certain.
Leaders of the BRICS - Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa -
invited the two as well as Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE),
Ethiopia and Egypt into the club at a summit this week in Johannesburg.
The move is aimed at increasing the BRICS' clout as a champion of
"Global South" nations, many of which feel unfairly treated by
international institutions dominated by the United States and other
wealthy nations.
The additions are a mixed bunch: Saudi Arabia and the UAE are wealthy
oil producers, inflation-wracked Argentina is desperate for foreign
investment, Iran is isolated by Western sanctions, Ethiopia is
recovering from a civil war and Egypt's economy is in crisis.
Some investors and economic analysts are sceptical that expansion will
lead to increased foreign direct investment (FDI) within the bloc.
"Egypt has already been expecting a lot of FDI from Saudi... and the
Gulf money is not coming - and it is not because they are not in the
BRICS organisation, it is because the proposition is not attractive,"
said Viktor Szabo, a portfolio manager at abrdn in London.
Still, BRICS leaders and other investors touted the increased economic
heft from the expansion. The new members would grow the bloc's share of
global GDP to 29% from 26% and trade in goods to 21% from 18%, Li Kexin,
a senior Chinese foreign ministry official, told a press briefing on
Thursday.
"I don't know if I would say it's a game changer, but in terms of
opening up consumer markets there is scale there," said Ola El-Shawarby,
deputy portfolio manager for the Emerging Markets Equity Strategy at Van
Eck in New York.
Increasing trade links between existing and prospective members of the
bloc have garnered attention.
"The growing trade interconnectedness seems to be providing some
fundamental ground for political announcements," said Chris Turner,
global head of markets at ING.
ING calculates that since 2015, the share of core BRICS in the new
candidates' imports increased from 23% to 30%, replacing the euro area,
the United States, and other developed economies.
[to top of second column] |
Delegates attend a meeting during the
2023 BRICS Summit at the Sandton Convention Centre in Johannesburg,
South Africa on August 24, 2023. Marco Longari/Pool via REUTERS/File
Photo
Other analysts and investors say Iran, which is under Western
sanctions, as well as the bloc's heavyweight member China - which
has long-pushed for enlargement - are among the main beneficiaries
of expansion.
"China and Brazil, India will benefit in terms of easy access to
oil, and Argentina and notably Iran will benefit in terms of access
to markets and FDI," said Jakob Ekholdt Christensen, senior emerging
markets fixed income strategist at BankInvest in Copenhagen.
"At most, the enlargement is a benefit for the new entrants that are
hungry for capital," said Hasnain Malik, a Dubai-based managing
director at Tellimer, an emerging markets research firm.
"But this assumes they would not have seen capital inflow anyway
from the richer BRICS countries and that any capital provided via a
BRICS institution does not jeopardise that from other multi and
bilateral sources."
A BRICS loan to Argentina could conflict with the bailouts it has
received from the International Monetary Fund, which has deeper
pockets, said abrdn's Szabo.
Increasing use of national currencies to reduce U.S. dollar
dependence was another goal BRICS leaders discussed at the summit in
Johannesburg. They said this could help lessen their economies'
vulnerability to a strong dollar and foreign exchange fluctuations.
And with oil producer heavyweights among the newcomers, investors
said this would feed speculation that Saudi Arabia might
increasingly switch to non-dollar-denominated currencies for oil
trade.
"The short-term consequences could be seen in oil," said Kaan Nazli,
a portfolio manager at asset manager Neuberger Berman in London.
"If oil gets priced in a currency other than the dollar for example,
or at least partly... that's a big change."
(Reporting by Rachel Savage and Karin Strohecker, Additional
reporting by Bansari Mayur Kamdar in Bangalore and Marc Jones and
Jorgelina do Rosario in London, Editing by Emelia Sithole-Matarise)
[© 2023 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.]
This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.
|