The law, which dates to 1931, was challenged by Josh Stein, now the
state's attorney general, who in 2020 was accused of making
derogatory statements in a campaign advertisement about Jim O'Neill,
then Stein's rival candidate for the office.
The state's Board of Elections spent eight months investigating the
complaint before recommending no charges be filed, reasoning that it
was not clear if the ad included a demonstrably false statement and
that, even if it did, applying the ban here might be
unconstitutional.
A local district attorney disagreed, and in 2022, a prosecutor told
Stein's campaign office that a grand jury was being convened to
bring charges against Stein.
Stein sued the district attorney in a federal district court, which
denied his request for a preliminary injunction to stop the grand
jury proceedings.
On Wednesday, a three-judge panel in the U.S. Court of Appeals for
Fourth Circuit granted the preliminary injunction, and ordered the
district court to continue the proceedings consistent with the
opinion issued on Wednesday.
The law in question makes it a misdemeanor to publish or circulate a
derogatory statement about a candidate for office while knowing it
to be false, or "in reckless disregard of its truth or falsity."
The panel was unanimous in finding the law likely violated the free
speech protections of the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment in two
ways. Firstly, by appearing to criminalize at least some truthful
statements; and secondly, the law entails "content-based
distinctions" by banning only campaign-related speech, which the
First Amendment forbids.
"Under this statute, speakers may lie with impunity about
businesspeople, celebrities, purely private citizens, or even
government officials so long as the victim is not currently a
'candidate in any primary or election,'" Judge Toby Heytens wrote.
"That is textbook content discrimination."
(Reporting by Jonathan Allen in New York; Editing by Marguerita
Choy)
[© 2023 Thomson Reuters. All rights
reserved.] Copyright 2022 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.
|
|