Ahead of cash bail’s end, state’s replacement pretrial justice system
takes shape
Send a link to a friend
[September 16, 2023]
By JERRY NOWICKI
& HANNAH MEISEL
Capitol News Illinois
news@capitolnewsillinois.com
Beginning Monday, state courts in Illinois will be prohibited from
jailing individuals who are accused – but not convicted – of crimes
simply because they cannot afford to post bail while they await trial.
Monetary bond will be abolished in favor of a system that seeks to give
judges authority to detain defendants accused of committing violent
crimes based on their level of risk to the community or of willful
flight from prosecution.
The new system will require more robust hearings when someone’s freedom
is on the line, while aiming to avoid disruptive pretrial incarceration
if the accused person’s offense was nonviolent and they are not deemed a
public safety or flight risk.
After a highly contentious election cycle last year in which Republicans
used the so-called Pretrial Fairness Act to attack Democrats for being
“soft on crime,” a series of legal challenges from state’s attorneys and
sheriffs delayed the law’s implementation while the Illinois Supreme
Court weighed its constitutionality. In a partisan 5-2 decision in July,
the court’s majority agreed that lawmaker-driven bail reform was
constitutional, setting up a Sept. 18 statewide rollout for the law,
more than nine months after the intended Jan. 1 start date.
State Sen. Robert Peters, D-Chicago, whose negotiations on the law made
him a national figure – and a lightning rod for criticism – said at the
time he knows the public debate over bail reform isn’t over, even if the
legal battle is.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2023/Sep/16/images/ads/current/longview_lda_FHG_2023.png)
“Let me be clear: Cash bail delegitimizes criminal justice systems and
transforms them into systems that violate public safety instead of
upholding it,” Peters said in a news release. “Illinois will not go
back. We will only move forward with our goal of ensuring public safety
for all Illinoisans, regardless of their background or financial
position.”
‘Detainable’ not equal to
‘handcuff-able’
The reform was driven by the Illinois Legislative Black Caucus in
January 2021 in the wake of George Floyd’s murder in Minneapolis as an
effort to address systemic racism in the criminal justice system. It was
part of the broader SAFE-T Act criminal justice reform – short for
Safety, Accountability, Fairness and Equity-Today.
An analysis of U.S. Department of Justice data by researchers at the
Loyola University of Chicago Center for Criminal Justice showed that in
2019, half of jail detainees in Illinois were Black compared to 15
percent of the state population; 33 percent were white compared to 76
percent of the population; and 14 percent were Hispanic compared to 18
percent of the population.
Of those jailed, 89 percent were being held pretrial.
The PFA’s multi-pronged approach to limiting pretrial detention starts
with law enforcement decisions in the field.
Under the law, officers retain the discretion to arrest any individual
they believe to be a threat to the public safety or if they believe an
arrest is the only way to keep the individual from continued violation
of the law, like when a person is trespassing.
One major change, however, is that it directs – but does not require –
officers to cite and release the individual if they are accused of a
crime below a Class A misdemeanor, with a court date to be scheduled
within 21 days.
Further changes occur at the judicial level after an arrest is made.
The PFA directly states the crimes and circumstances under which a judge
can order an individual jailed as they await trial.
After weathering months of criticism and election season misinformation
campaigns over the SAFE-T Act, Democratic lawmakers in December added to
the list of offenses considered “detainable,” including any felony that
involved the “threat of or infliction of great bodily harm or permanent
disability or disfigurement.”
Another subset of crimes become detainable if a judge believes the
defendant to be a flight risk.
Loyola’s CCJ analyzed arrest data from 2020 and 2021, concluding that a
judge would not have been able to detain the defendant in 56 percent of
arrests that occurred over that span had the PFA been in place.
But another analysis by the CCJ showed only 19 percent of individuals
with pending felony cases were in jail while awaiting trial on average
from 2017 through 2019, with another 17 percent on electronic monitoring
or pretrial supervision.
That means about 64 percent of individuals awaiting trial for felony
charges over that timespan were living in the community without any sort
of supervision, the study found.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2023/Sep/16/images/ads/current/chicagostreet_quarter_FAIR_2023.png)
The research didn’t predict whether more or fewer defendants will be
jailed while awaiting trial once the PFA takes effect. It did, however,
predict that those facing lower-level charges will likely spend less
time in jail, while stays may be lengthened for those accused of violent
crime because they can no longer free themselves on bail if a judge
orders them detained.
Lake County State’s Attorney Eric Rinehart, who supported the PFA, said
the distinction between the law’s changes to judicial and law
enforcement authority led to much of the misinformation that surrounded
it in a contentious 2022 election season.
“The word ‘detainable’ became intermixed with the word ‘handcuff-able’…
and I think police officers thought that they were going to be checking
their cheat sheet under the SAFE-T Act as to whether or not they could
handcuff a retail theft (suspect),” he said. “Police officers were
directed not to cuff cooperative individuals who were not a threat to
anyone, who were accused of committing a very small class of crimes,
what we call (class) B and C misdemeanors.”
Those misdemeanors include such crimes as low-level property offenses
that do not include violence.
Rinehart spoke at a media briefing this week organized by domestic
violence survivor advocacy groups. Those groups, which worked with
lawmakers to draft the law, noted it gives judges greater authority than
previous law to detain individuals accused of domestic violence.
Madeleine Behr, policy director at the Chicago Alliance Against Sexual
Exploitation, said state’s attorneys will – for the first time – be
required to notify victims when a defendant has an initial detention
hearing. The state will also be required to notify victims about the
ability to obtain protective orders at the time of the initial and
subsequent hearings.
Loyola researchers estimated 33 percent of those arrested in 2020 and
2021 would have been detainable based on their risk to the public, while
11 percent would have been detainable under the willful flight standard.
Domestic violence charges or violations of an order of protection made
up about half the cases in which a person would have been detainable,
per the research, as a detention hearing is required under the law when
a defendant has violated an order of protection.
“And this really came from our community,” Behr said in the media
briefing. “This came from our input – it's recognizing the lethality and
the harm at play when these kinds of violations happen.”
‘Least restrictive’ method necessary
One directive of the Pretrial Fairness Act was to ensure an individual’s
appearance in court through the “least restrictive” means, meaning
pretrial incarceration should be used only when necessary to ensure
public safety.
For many counties, that could mean greater reliance on electronic
monitoring, a type of GPS tracking that requires the defendant to wear
an ankle bracelet and be tracked remotely by justice system
professionals.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2023/Sep/16/images/ads/current/culligan_sda_FOOTBALL_2023.png)
[to top of second column]
|
![Ahead of cash bail’s end, state’s replacement pretrial justice system takes shape](../images/091623PIX/700700p718EDNmainimg-THEIS-SCOIL-Sworn-in-09181_small.JPG)
The Illinois Supreme Court chamber is pictured in Springfield.
(Capitol News Illinois file photo)
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2023/Sep/16/images/ads/current/napa_lda_FILTERSALE_090623.png)
The PFA gives individuals on electronic monitoring two days each week to
move freely to accomplish daily tasks – a departure from previous law.
That provision has been ridiculed by conservatives and law enforcement
groups who say that it grants too much freedom.
In 71 of Illinois’ 102 counties, electronic monitoring will be overseen
by the Supreme Court’s Office of Statewide Pretrial Services, a newly
formed state agency designed to assist counties with the PFA’s
implementation and to fulfill a 1987 law that required all circuit
courts to offer pretrial services.
It received a $23 million state appropriation for the current fiscal
year after a $26 million allotment last year, which included allocations
for start-up costs.
For OSPS-affiliated counties, defendants ordered to wear ankle monitors
will have their movements tracked from a centralized location in
Springfield with round-the-clock staffing. Electronic monitoring
officers ensure defendants aren’t approaching geographically marked
“exclusion zones” where the individual is prohibited from approaching.
Those could include a perimeter around a person’s home if they are on
house arrest or around a victim’s home if the defendant is the subject
of an order of protection.
“If we have an exclusion zone case, or we have a situation where we
think a defendant is attempting to remove their device, we can contact
law enforcement and seek their assistance to help us remedy or respond
to a violation,” retired judge Cara Smith, director of the OSPS, said in
an interview.
Electronic monitoring can only be ordered by a judge, and the mission of
the OSPS is to carry out those monitoring requirements once they are
ordered. It’s one of several services the office offers to its member
courts.
The Illinois Network for Pretrial Justice advocacy organization,
however, is wary of expanding the use of electronic monitoring in the
wake of cash bond’s end.
“Requiring anyone to wear an ankle shackle and be monitored in lieu of
having to pay bond is an injustice that is in direct conflict with the
spirit of the law and its intended impact,” the organization said in a
statement.
The OSPS also pays for electronic monitoring services in its counties,
costs that were previously borne by the defendant in many counties.
A new process takes shape
Under previous law, bail hearings typically occurred within 72 hours of
arrest, lasting fewer than five minutes. Prosecutors would detail the
defendant’s charges and potentially recommend a bail amount. The judge
would then decide the conditions of their release, including how much
money, if any, the defendant must post before their release.
The overhaul of the system was driven by the concern that decisions
about a person’s freedom weren’t receiving enough scrutiny in court.
Beginning Monday, it will still be up to state’s attorneys to petition
the court to detain an individual prior to their trial. But upon that
petition, a new, more robust pretrial process will begin. Under it, the
defendant is given the right to legal representation at their first
hearing, with the detention hearing typically taking place within 24 or
48 hours of the first appearance in court.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2023/Sep/16/images/ads/current/graue_lda_ENCLAVE3169preowned_081423.jpg)
The new process allows a defendant to have a public defender or private
attorney at their first appearance, while also placing a greater
emphasis on counties to provide pretrial services aimed at assuring a
defendant’s appearance in court while also connecting them with supports
focused on limiting recidivism.
For Nathan Rowland, a part-time contract public defender for Gallatin
and Hamilton counties in the far southeastern corner of Illinois, that
means he’ll be busier than ever before in his two-decade career as a
public defender. Rowland, who works out of his private office in
McLeansboro, said he still has many unanswered questions as to how the
system will work.
But he also said he believes the justice system has for years been
“lazily” substituting high-dollar bonds for “a particularized
dangerousness finding,” which will be a requirement for keeping a
defendant in jail under the PFA. And for many of his low-income clients
– especially those accused of non-violent crimes – abolishing cash bail
will mean they won’t languish in jail simply because they can’t afford
to post bond.
“You get removed from your life and when you come back to it two weeks
later or three months later, it's in complete shambles,” Rowland said of
individuals who are detained pretrial.
On Aug. 30, the Supreme Court issued an order allowing counties to hold
detention hearings remotely through March 18, 2024, due to the
anticipated volume of new cases and limited resources in certain areas
of the state.
A new state agency takes shape
Of Illinois’ 102 counties, 31 have administered their own pretrial
services for a varying number of years. The other 71 will be served by
the OSPS.
Smith said the agency she leads has grown from about 10 employees in
June 2022 to more than 170, and it is up and running in 70 counties,
with Will County to be added to the list in October. It’s secured office
space in 47 counties in addition to its central operations center in
Springfield.
Its employees work to connect individuals with such support services as
drug or behavioral health treatment, anger management or any other
conditions imposed by the court. It also sends text message reminders of
hearings among other outreach and scheduling efforts.
But perhaps its most important task alongside electronic monitoring,
Smith said, was offering a “neutral” report about a defendant’s history
to judges, public defenders and state’s attorneys prior to a first
appearance in court.
Those reports take about an hour to prepare and usually include an
interview with the defendant, a process that starts with identifying new
defendants daily and carving out time to conduct interviews. The agency
has completed more than 18,000 such investigations since August 2022,
Smith said.
Smith said when she was a judge in juvenile court in Cook County, “you
didn't have sort of that neutral presentation.”
The presentation, she said, includes: “’Here's what we know about this
individual,’ including a detailed criminal history, if it exists, and
information about, ‘are they employed, are they in school? What's the
home situation like?’”
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2023/Sep/16/images/ads/current/lincolnheating_lda_FHG_2023.png)
Rowland said those services have been invaluable, noting he’d often
enter a hearing room without knowing anything about the defendant he was
about to represent.
The “million-dollar question,” Smith said, is how the office can best
support individuals to limit them from reoffending.
“We have a support services staff who look to identify resources that
might help a person succeed,” she said. “But you know, we will have –
and there always have been – pretrial failures where someone… continues
to engage in criminal activity.”
The new system, Smith said, will provide a more targeted approach for
detention.
“I think the idea under the PFA is that we'll be better able to identify
people whose dangerousness is such that they should be detained
pretrial, and everyone else is out,” she said.
Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news
service covering state government. It is distributed to hundreds of
newspapers, radio and TV stations statewide. It is funded primarily by
the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation,
along with major contributions from the Illinois Broadcasters Foundation
and Southern Illinois Editorial Association. |