US Senate defeats border deal, but Ukraine, Israel aid may survive

[February 08, 2024]  By Patricia Zengerle, Makini Brice and Richard Cowan

WASHINGTON (Reuters) -Republicans in the U.S. Senate on Wednesday defeated a bipartisan effort to bolster border security that had taken months to negotiate, but said they could still approve aid for Ukraine and Israel that had been tied up in the deal.

By a vote of 49-50, largely along party lines, the Senate failed to approve a $118 billion bipartisan package that would tighten immigration laws, help Ukraine fight a Russian invasion and bolster Israel in its war with Hamas.

The measure needed 60 votes to advance in the chamber, which Democrats control by a 51-49 margin.

For months, Republicans have insisted that any additional aid to the two U.S. allies must also address the high numbers of migrants arriving at the U.S-Mexico border - a top voter concern.

But many Republicans promptly rejected the package when it was released on Sunday, even though it contained many of their priorities. Former President Donald Trump, who has pressed them to reject any compromise, has made calls for tight controls of immigration a feature of his campaign to defeat Democratic President Joe Biden in the November election.

Only four of the Senate's 49 Republicans voted for the bill.

"Some have been very clear with me they have political differences with the bill," said Republican Senator James Lankford, one of the negotiators.

"They say it's the wrong time to solve the problem, let the presidential election solve the problem."

Independent Senator Kyrsten Sinema, another one of the deal's authors, said she was baffled by the sudden shift in fortune.

"Three weeks ago, everyone wanted to solve the border crisis," she said. "Yesterday, nobody did."

Still, the defeat of the bill left open the possibility that Congress could yet provide much-needed aid to U.S. allies. The Senate was expected to vote on Thursday on a $96 billion package that strips out the immigration provisions but leaves the foreign aid intact.

An aide to Republican Senator Roger Wicker had predicted that a foreign-aid package would get well over 60 votes in the 100-seat chamber - a rare show of cross-party support.

ACTION DELAYED

But Senate leaders delayed action for hours instead, as Republicans sought to agree behind closed doors on a set of amendments that could revive the border debate and modify provisions to aid Ukraine and Israel.

U.S. Senator Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV) holds up a challenge coin given to her by a border patrol officer during the weekly Democratic Caucus lunch press conference at the U.S. Capitol building in Washington, U.S., February 6, 2024. REUTERS/Amanda Andrade-Rhoades

Republican Senator John Cornyn said party members were aiming to come up with amendments on border security and on the distribution of aid to U.S. allies.

"The question is what other amendments do people need in order to allow us to go to final passage," the Texas Republican told reporters.

Cornyn said he was optimistic about reaching a deal but expressed skepticism that an agreement could be ironed out later on Wednesday.

On Wednesday evening, the Senate Democratic Majority Leader Chuck Schumer announced that the vote would be put off at least until Thursday, to allow time for Republicans to determine their party's way forward.

"We will have this vote tomorrow," Schumer said.

Even if it passes, the aid faces uncertain prospects in the House of Representatives, as Republicans who control that chamber have balked at further support for Ukraine.

"We'll see what the Senate does. We're allowing the process to play out," House Speaker Mike Johnson told reporters.

Johnson had said the border package would be "dead on arrival" in his chamber.

Johnson, meanwhile, said on Wednesday he would hold another vote to impeach Biden's top border official, Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, after a first attempt failed in a 214-216 vote on Tuesday.

"It was a mess what happened here, but we're cleaning it up," he told reporters on Wednesday.

(Reporting by Richard Cowan, Patricia Zengerle, Makini Brice, David Morgan and Andy Sullivan; Writing by Andy Sullivan; Editing by David Gregorio and Christopher Cushing)

[© 2024 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.]This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.  Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.