Can Ukraine supporters force a US House vote on foreign aid?
Send a link to a friend
[March 13, 2024]
By Patricia Zengerle
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - As U.S. House of Representatives Speaker Mike
Johnson refuses to allow a vote on the $95 billion foreign security aid
bill passed by the Senate, supporters are turning to rare and
complicated procedural tools to try to force a vote.
Democratic Representative Jim McGovern filed a discharge petition on
Tuesday and has started to collect signatures and according to media
reports, Republican Representative Brian Fitzpatrick also has a petition
in the works.
Fitzpatrick's office did not respond to a request for comment.
Here is an explanation of the discharge petition and other legislative
maneuvers advocates for Ukraine aid might try.
WHAT IS A DISCHARGE PETITION?
The House "discharge rule," which is generally the only procedure by
which members can secure consideration of a bill without cooperation
from majority party House leadership, requires at least 218 signatures,
a majority of the House's members, according to the Congressional
Research Service.
If the petition gets 218 signatures, the House must vote on a motion to
discharge. If that passes, the House would then vote on the Senate bill.
IS THERE ENOUGH SUPPORT FOR A PETITION TO SUCCEED?
It would be close.
Many Republicans favor the foreign aid bill - estimates are that about
70% of the House would vote yes if Johnson allowed a vote - but signing
a discharge petition would be a major, public break from party
leadership in an election year with every House seat up for grabs and
Republicans fighting to protect a slim majority.
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2024/Mar/13/images/ads/current/ldn_sda_NILA_010924.png)
Former President Donald Trump, the favorite to be the 2024 Republican
presidential nominee, has criticized aid for Ukraine and his endorsement
or opposition can make or break a Republican's campaign.
Johnson, a close Trump ally who voted against Ukraine aid before
becoming speaker, has insisted that any package of international
assistance must also include measures to address security at the U.S.
border with Mexico, despite Senate Republicans rejecting legislation to
do so at Trump's urging.
[to top of second column]
|
![](../images/031324PIX/news_r34.jpg)
U.S. House of Representatives Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA) enters a
room for a press conference at Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S.,
February 14, 2024. REUTERS/Leah Millis/File Photo
![](http://archives.lincolndailynews.com/2024/Mar/13/images/ads/current/graue_lda_chevysilverado4069_030424.jpg)
There are also an unknown number of Democrats - estimates are four
to eight - who might refuse to sign because of the $14 billion in
aid to Israel included in the bill. Some have criticized the bill
given the high number of civilian deaths tied to Israel's campaign
in Gaza, and difficulties getting aid to Palestinians.
Members from both parties also question whether Washington should be
sending money abroad rather than focusing on domestic needs and warn
against potential involvement in broader conflicts.
DO DISCHARGE PETITIONS EVER WORK?
They do, but only rarely. The last time was in 2015, when 42
Republicans defied party leaders to join Democrats who favored
reauthorizing the then-shuttered Export-Import Bank. In 2002, a
discharge petition was successfully used to pass the Bipartisan
Campaign Reform Act, which became known as McCain-Feingold.
WHAT IS THIS 'PREVIOUS QUESTION?'
Democrats are also considering another procedure, known as
"defeating the previous question," where a majority of lawmakers can
force an immediate vote on a bill that leadership has not brought to
the floor.
Every time the House brings a bill to the floor under a rule, such
as one limiting the number of amendments, there is a vote on "moving
the previous question." If that is defeated, Democrats can amend the
rule to bring up any bill.
That procedure would work quickly and requires only a majority of
House members voting and present - not the full 218 needed for a
discharge petition. But it has almost never been successful and also
would require perhaps two dozen Republicans to break with
leadership.
(Reporting by Patricia Zengerle, editing by Don Durfee and
Marguerita Choy)
[© 2024 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.]This material
may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content. |