'The Batman,' a 2022 blockbuster, wasn't plagiarized, US judge rules

[March 28, 2024]  By Jonathan Stempel

NEW YORK (Reuters) - Warner Bros Entertainment didn't steal the plot for its 2022 blockbuster "The Batman" from a writer who created a story about the caped crusader three decades earlier, a federal judge in Manhattan ruled on Wednesday.

U.S. District Judge Paul Engelmayer also said the writer Christopher Wozniak infringed copyrights belonging to DC Comics, which employed him as a freelance artist in 1990 when he wrote "The Ultimate Riddle," later retitled "The Blind Man's Hat."

"We respectfully disagree with the court's decision and are considering our next steps," Wozniak's lawyer, Terry Parker, said in an email.

Wozniak claimed he was "stunned" to learn that "The Batman" was a near copy of "The Ultimate Riddle," with the Riddler terrorizing a Gotham City beset by crime and controlled by a corrupt banking cartel.

But in a 45-page decision, Engelmayer said Wozniak intentionally and without consent lifted material from DC Comics' works to create his story, which "liberally exploits --indeed, is rife with" Batman characters and plot elements.

"The story's use of the Batman character and the surrounding protected elements is an act of clear and blatant copyright infringement," the judge wrote.

Engelmayer also said key similarities between the works --serial killers who are loners bent on destroying society, villains who taunt pursuers with "clues and riddles," and moments of "clarity or epiphany" that propel villains to crime -- were too commonplace to support Wozniak's copyright claim.

NYPD officers pose next to a "Batmobile" during the New York Premiere of "The Batman", in New York City, U.S. March 1, 2022. REUTERS/Caitlin Ochs/File Photo

For the latter, the judge in a footnote cited movies including "Star Wars: Episode III -- Revenge of the Sith," where Anakin Skywalker succumbs to the dark side of the Force and becomes Darth Vader.

Engelmayer also rejected Wozniak's "wholly speculative" claim for how Warner Bros might have gotten access to his story.

A lawyer for Warner Bros and DC Comics had no immediate comment.

Wozniak sued Warner Bros in October 2022. DC Comics, which has thousands of copyrights dating to 1941 for Batman works, sued Wozniak two months later.

"The Batman" starred Robert Pattinson as Batman, Zoe Kravitz as Catwoman and Paul Dano as the Riddler.

It received mixed to positive reviews, and grossed more than $772 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo.

The cases are Wozniak v Warner Bros Entertainment Inc and DC Comics v Wozniak, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 22-08969.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Sandra Maler)

[© 2024 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.]  This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.  Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.