Israel's domestic security chief accuses Netanyahu of making improper
demands of him as rift deepens
[April 22, 2025]
By TIA GOLDENBERG
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) —
The head of Israel’s internal security service on Monday accused Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of trying to exploit the power of the agency
for political and personal gain through a litany of improper demands.
His comments deepened a showdown between the two men that has divided
the nation.
In a submission to the Supreme Court, Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar wrote
that he refused a request from Netanyahu to identify Israeli
anti-government protesters and surveil their financial backers.
Bar said he also was told to obey Netanyahu and not the courts in the
event of a constitutional crisis. And he said there were attempts to
force him to sign a document that would make it nearly impossible for
Netanyahu to testify in his corruption trial because of security
concerns, something he said he rejected doing.
Netanyahu’s office called Bar’s affidavit “full of lies.”
The affidavit was the latest salvo in a deepening rift between Netanyahu
and the Shin Bet, which monitors Palestinian militant groups and is seen
as having played a major role in failing to prevent Hamas' Oct. 7, 2023,
attacks that sparked the war in Gaza.
Netanyahu moved to fire Bar last month over what he said was a crisis of
confidence surrounding Hamas’ attacks. The step to dismiss Bar sparked
an uproar in Israel because it came as the agency is investigating ties
between the Israeli leader’s office and the Gulf Arab state of Qatar — a
key mediator between Hamas and Israel over the war in Gaza. Critics say
the firing is tainted by a conflict of interest meant to derail that
probe, a charge Netanyahu denies.
[to top of second column]
|
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attends his trial on
corruption charges at the district court in Tel Aviv, Israel,
Monday, April 21, 2025. (Moti Kimchi/Pool Photo via AP)
Israel’s Supreme Court froze Bar’s firing following multiple legal
challenges against the move. In a hearing earlier this month, it
called on the sides to reach a compromise on Bar’s dismissal. The
affidavit was submitted as part of deliberations on the firing.
The Shin Bet is meant to be apolitical, but Bar has accused
Netanyahu of demanding personal loyalty. He said he was submitting
his affidavit to ensure the agency’s “professional independence as
well as its ability to refuse to carry out improper orders.”
Netanyahu's office said Bar's affidavit was further proof of the
Shin Bet chief's failures surrounding Oct. 7. Responding to Bar's
accusations, it said Netanyahu made no illegal requests against the
protesters but rather asked for stricter enforcement against what he
said was their “violent incitement.” The statement denied Netanyahu
had sought to disrupt his testimony.
Netanyahu has sought repeatedly to cast blame for Hamas' attacks on
his security chiefs, despite mounting public pressure that he accept
responsibility for failing to prevent the Oct. 7 assault. Bar, in
the early weeks of the war, accepted blame for his role in the
blunder and has said he would resign in due time. Netanyahu,
meanwhile, has resisted calls for an official governmental probe
into the military and intelligence failures surrounding the attack.
All contents © copyright 2025 Associated Press. All rights reserved |
