Trump wants to use the 'God Squad' to increase logging, but it must
follow strict rules
[March 05, 2025]
By TAMMY WEBBER
President Donald Trump wants to increase logging in national forests and
on public lands, including by bypassing endangered species protections.
To do that, the federal government would have to activate a seldom-used
committee nicknamed the “God Squad” because it can approve federal
projects even if it leads to extinction of a species otherwise protected
by the Endangered Species Act.
But experts say there are strict procedural requirements — and no
provision under law to proactively use the committee to bypass
protections.
Here's what to know:
What does Trump want?
The president on Saturday signed actions to increase domestic lumber
production in national forests and other public lands, directing federal
agencies to look for ways to bypass protections for endangered species.
Upon taking office in January, Trump declared a national energy
emergency and directed the committee to convene at least quarterly to
either consider exemptions or, if there are none, “to identify obstacles
to domestic energy infrastructure” related to the Endangered Species Act
or the Marine Mammal Protection Act. The Endangered Species Act makes it
illegal to harm or kill protected species and has led to restrictions on
logging, mining and oil and gas development. The Marine Mammal
Protection Act bans killing and harassment of marine mammals with some
limited exceptions.
What is the God Squad?
Officially called the Endangered Species Committee, it was established
in 1978 as a way to exempt projects from Endangered Species Act
protections if a cost-benefit analysis concluded it was the only way to
achieve net economic benefits in the national or regional interest.
In the case of logging, the analysis also should determine if the
benefits of cutting trees outweigh the economic value of watershed and
other protections provided by standing timber, said Patrick Parenteau,
an emeritus professor at the Vermont Law and Graduate School who helped
write criteria for the God Squad.
[to top of second column]
|
Sun shines through Douglas fir trees in the Willamette National
Forest, Ore., Oct. 27, 2023. (AP Photo/Amanda Loman, File)
The seven-member committee is led by the secretary of the Interior
and includes the secretaries of Agriculture and the Army,
administrators of the Environmental Protection Agency and National
Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the chairman of the
Council of Economic Advisers. Affected states also would be
represented with one vote total, meaning multiple states would each
get a fraction of a vote.
Five votes are required for an exemption.
When can the God Squad be convened?
The secretary of the Interior can convene the committee only for a
specific project and only if the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service or
the National Marine Fisheries Service — after a required
environmental review — concludes the project would jeopardize
survival of a protected species, Parenteau said.
Otherwise, “there is no basis to convene the God Squad,” he said.
“Contrary to what Trump has been talking about, you don’t convene
this committee to grant exemptions prospectively. That is not legal.
There’s no jurisdiction for the committee to even be convened to do
that.”
What has the committee done in the past?
Only twice in its 47 years has the committee issued exemptions. The
first allowed construction of a dam on a section of the Platte River
considered critical habitat for whooping cranes. But a negotiated
settlement won significant protections that led to overall ecosystem
improvement and a rebounded crane population.
The second exemption, during the George H.W. Bush administration,
was for logging in northern spotted owl habitat. But the Bureau of
Land Management under President Bill Clinton withdrew the request
after environmental groups sued, arguing that the committee’s
decision was political and violated legal procedures.
All contents © copyright 2025 Associated Press. All rights reserved |
