Judge reduces Menendez brothers' murder sentences, putting them a step
closer to freedom
[May 14, 2025]
By JAIMIE DING
LOS ANGELES (AP) — Erik and Lyle Menendez will have a new shot at
freedom after 35 years behind bars for murdering their parents, a judge
ruled Tuesday.
The ruling from Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Michael Jesic
reduced the brothers' sentences from life in prison without parole to 50
years to life, making them immediately eligible for parole. The state
parole board must decide whether to release them.
The judge's decision followed months of pushback from prosecutors who
opposed resentencing, arguing the brothers hadn't taken adequate
responsibility for their crimes. Ultimately prosecutors did not call any
witnesses, saying they had presented all of their evidence.
The defense turned to family members and those who knew the brothers
since their conviction to speak to their character and rehabilitation.
The brothers also addressed the court via video as family members
listened on tearfully. Most of the brothers’ family members, including
aunts and uncles, have long supported their bid for freedom.
“On Aug. 20, 1989, I killed my mom and dad. I make no excuses and also
no justification,” Lyle Menendez said, choking up as he addressed the
room. “The impact of my violent actions on my family ... is
unfathomable.”
A fast decision
Jesic issued his decision immediately after the brothers spoke. The
hearing was slated to last two days, but Jesic made his decision in one,
offering the brothers new hope after years of unsuccessful appeals and
attempts to win freedom in a case that has captured public attention
from the start.
The brothers were convicted in 1996 for murdering their father, Jose
Menendez — a powerful record executive — and their mother, Kitty
Menendez, in their Beverly Hills home in 1989. The brothers were 18 and
21 at the time. While defense attorneys argued the brothers acted out of
self-defense after years of sexual abuse by their father, prosecutors
said the brothers killed their parents for a multimillion-dollar
inheritance.
While the sentence reduction is a major win for the brothers, defense
attorney Mark Geragos said he had been seeking to have their charges
reduced to manslaughter, which would have allowed them be immediately
released. The judge did not go that far.
“I’m not saying they should be released; it’s not for me to decide,”
Jesic said. “I do believe they’ve done enough in the past 35 years, that
they should get that chance.”
The brothers have an appearance before the parole board on June 13 as
part of a risk assessment report ordered by California Gov. Gavin Newsom
to aid in his clemency decision.
Erik Menendez also spoke about taking responsibility for his actions and
apologized to his family.
“You did not deserve what I did to you, but you inspire me to do
better,” he said.
The judge said he was especially moved by a letter from a prison
official who supported resentencing, something the official had never
done for any incarcerated person in the 25 years of his career.
[to top of second column]
|
This combination of two booking photos provided by the California
Department of Corrections shows Erik Menendez, left, and Lyle
Menendez. (California Dept. of Corrections via AP, File)
Defense witnesses spoke of brothers' character
The defense called several of the brothers’ cousins, a former judge
and a former fellow inmate to the witness stand to testify that the
brothers were not only rehabilitated but helped others. Prosecutors
cross-examined the witnesses but didn’t call any of their own.
“We all, on both sides of the family, believe that 35 years is
enough,” said Anamaria Baralt, a cousin. “They are universally
forgiven by our family.”
Diane Hernandez, a cousin who also testified during the brothers'
first trial, spoke about the abuse she witnessed in the Menendez
household when she lived with them.
“When Jose was with one of the boys … you couldn’t even go up the
stairs to be on the same floor,” Hernandez said of the brothers'
father.
The Associated Press does not typically name people who say they
have been sexually abused unless they come forward publicly.
“They are a real family,” said Mark Geragos, the brothers’ lead
attorney, after the hearing. “Real people who have lived through
unimaginable horrors. And I’m hopeful and glad that we’re one huge
step closer to bringing the boys home.”
Los Angeles County prosecutors argued against the resentencing. Los
Angeles District Attorney Nathan Hochman has said the brothers had
not taken complete responsibility for the crime.
Geragos emphasized that the purpose of resentencing is to “encourage
rehabilitation," not relitigate the original crime.
“We have evolved,” Geragos said. “This is not the ’90s anymore. We
have a more robust understanding of a lot of things.”
Former district attorney and family support resentencing
The previous LA County District Attorney George Gascón had opened
the door to possible freedom for the brothers last fall by asking a
judge to reduce their sentences. Since their conviction, the
brothers have gotten an education, participated in self-help classes
and started various support groups for fellow people in prison, his
office said in a petition.
A former judge who said he considered himself tough on crime,
Jonathan Colby, told the court that spending time with the brothers
and witnessing their growth made him believe in rehabilitation.
Anerae Brown, who had been formerly incarcerated, cried as he
testified about how the brothers helped him heal and eventually be
released through parole.
“I have children now,” he said. “Without Lyle and Erik I might still
be sitting in there doing stupid things.”
All contents © copyright 2025 Associated Press. All rights reserved
 |
