REVIEW

Kate Earl's writing is iffy on 'Stronger'

By AP's Ron Harris

[November 20, 2012]  NEW YORK (AP) -- Kate Earl, "Stronger" (Downtown)

Kate Earl admits to feeling a tad lost before completing her third album, "Stronger." Seems she was stuck performing someone else's vision and only now has she begun to realize one of her own.

The trouble with "Stronger" is that Earl's vision is an ineffectual grasp at simple substance through song. The soft-rock tunes are too simple and the results too routine.

Earl gallops into view atop the horse trot cadenced title track, "Stronger," in which she lauds the hard road traveled to relevance and maturity. That would all be great fodder for a song if she'd come up with better lyrics.

It gets worse. "One Woman Army" sounds too much like 10,000 Maniac's "Like The Weather." "California" sounds way too much like The Steve Miller Band's "The Joker" -- and you get the idea. Earl is too close to her reference material, which weakens her own vision.

She has a smooth, pleasing voice and when you sound (and look) like Earl you get a second and perhaps a third chance to make it in music. But even the deft hand of seasoned musicians like Brett Dennen and Blake Mills can't salvage this artistically tepid release.

CHECK OUT THIS TRACK: On "Loyalty," Earl finally displays some of the rough-edged hurt that the album could have used more of. Sad strains of reverbed guitar back her nicely as she sings of rescuing a friend in need.

[Associated Press; By RON HARRIS]

Follow Ron Harris on Twitter: http://twitter.com/Journorati.

Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.